#1 Malcolm Reynolds (FLY) v. #2 Xander Harris (BTVS)

[Mr Trick]

Thought it'd be closer, but agree with nightshade's logic for why Xander came up a bit short.

 

[ChaseRules]

This one doesn't surprise me, Mal is a great character, and Xander does divide people

I have to agree. Have a feeling Mal was going to win for that very reason

 

[Athena]

Mal may not have seven seasons behind him, but he's by far the better character. Deserving winner IMO.

 

[Ethan Reigns]

I am kind of like Angel in his attitude towards Xander as excerpted from "Enemies 3ABB17":

XANDER (cont'd)
Man, where've you been? You gotta
find Buffy - she's going to her place
and stocking up on...

CRACK! Without looking or breaking stride, Angel lashes out a mean right hand and cracks Xander across the jaw. Xander crumples to a heap, unconscious before he even hits the ground.
Angel and Faith just keep walking, out of frame.

ANGEL
(deadpan)
That guy just bugs me.

They keep going...