I agree! Season 4 Giles is super hot!!!His singing and Band Candy makes him more appealing to me than other lead male like Xander or Riley!Yes, he is most attractive when singing, no matter what he's wearing. S4 Giles appeals to me most, I like that he lets loose a little and drunk Giles is a laugh.
I like the tongue in cheek theory that those who aren't cute tend to vanish from being ignored (like Marcie), unless you can't ignore them like Snyder.Good question. No idea. Both Olivia and Jenny were cast with models, which says to me, this woman is supposed to be more attractive than an average actress. Anya also seemed taken with him in Tabula, and we know she's supposed to be cute. But frankly, it's too hard. This isn't Ghostbusters, actors are rarely unattractive in this day and age.