Did Warren still die in your headcanon?
If not, who does the First appear to Andrew as if not Warren?
No. He did not die in my headcannon. After he succesfully escaped Dark Willow, he moved away from Sunnydale, met a nice girlfriend, got married and become a dad. I'm joking!!!!!😂 More seriously, after he left Sunnydale, he decided to form his own gang but got rejected. And still a nerd. He became better at fighting, more intelligent but still a human villain with no special powers, still despising women although not as Caleb. His cheeky attitude remaining, outgoing and confident like in season 6. However encountering a character development without giving him a tragic background or making him an anti hero or anti villain. No, he would remain a realistic sociopathic remorseless villain but at the at the same time keeping him lame and being looked down by the underworld.
So do you love my headcannon?