I know, I'm weird, but this is NOT one of my favs. Maybe because I am also not a giant fan of "The Wish". I DO like it better than The Wish though.
I DO like when everyone thinks Willow's dead and she walks in. I ALSO love Angel walking in to tell them. THAT'S funny!
I like Willow trying to act like she's evil too. It's very funny.
What I've never gotten is why Anya's so gung ho to prove it's NOT evil Willow. She's not really a demon anymore, so why would she care? In fact, SHE'S the one who dragged Willow into this whole mess, so if she ever wants help again, one would think she'd want to HELP Willow rather than throw her at the feet of the other vampires to die.
I also think it's just one of Joss's EVIL plots to have us want Vamp Willow to live for Willow's sake and then WHAMMO dead. Couldn't we just have sent her back and ASSUMED she was dead and not have to actually see it?
Just my two cents.