Well, everybody here has a favorite character or two, and also a character or two that rubs them the wrong way, or simply just is not their favorite. Just saying. Personally, I really loved Faith's arc in S8, and it was my second favorite arc of that season. Post S8, I really find her being more of Echo than Faith. Maybe because I cannot 'get her' in the comics media, or maybe because putting her 'on the title' in my opinion steals half the space that would have been Angel's. I think I would really enjoy Faith spin off though, it is just the A&F format past and present that makes me wish Faith was in her own book.
Also 'character growth' as an idiom really really irks me every time I see it used. Root vegetables and cysts 'grow'; characters develop - in real stories with beginnings and endings anyhow. In Whedon's stories though, maybe because they are so serialized by nature (?), everybody has to go through a dark stage or two, or three, or five , because by his own admission he finds 'heroes' boring. His 'redemption arcs' don't stick either, because once the character is 'on the path of goodness and correction', they have to be destroyed all over again or it 'becomes boring'. So, nyeah-ah, I am not buying new and all mature Faith just yet, because I kind of (also) find her boring ? I hope she gets into another interesting self-destructive arc, (that obviously will end with another redemption), but other than that I don't find her any 'richer' in the comics. Maybe because in the comics as well as in the original tv series Faith never has any meaningful relationships that don't end up with her being jealous of her newly found 'ship' going back to Buffy? Maybe because she dumps everybody who is good for her, because she is afraid to get too attached? I don't know. I wish Robin Wood will become a part of her circle - if only to see Faith react and show some emotion other than 'it feels like mine, so it is probably yours'.
I do see your point, Faith has developed, what I meant was
matured, but I didn't find her struggle in A&F boring, she still screwed up a few times ('Daddy Issues' springs to mind.) and by the end hadn't really come out ahead (she loses the slayers she was in charge of, loses Nadira to vengeance, she loses Giles as he decides to ditch her, again, for Buffy. That's why she wants to try her own path.)
Faith hasn't been near Buffy since S8, and the writers seem content in keeping them seperate, which I find disappointing. I would like to see them bond, just a little, and who knows, maybe its finally on the cards. Their relationship needs to, in your words,
develop into something else that's less antagonistic.
And I disagree slightly, Faith has had plenty of good relationships, with Angel, with Wesley (partly why I would like him to return, in ghost form or something) and Giles (both old and youthified) spring to mind.
But I would like to see a
romantic relationship for Faith, which I think is what you were getting at. I'd like to see her develop in that direction, because it is really fertile ground for her character that's so far completely untouched. There are so many stories there to deal with her 'man-issues'.
Faith's relationship with Wood bored the hell out of me from the get-go, there was intial attraction, she'd been in jail for three years, he had a thing for slayers, and that was it.
🙄
I saw little evidence that he was a 'nice guy' in his interactions with her. I'm glad they ditched it at the first opportunity and went on to something else.
🙂
Oh, and there indications in the comics that Faith is going to foul up again, big time. So you might get your wish...