Any 5 Stars

[Joamna]

Amy Acker
Amber Benson
James Marsters
Joss Whedon
Marti Noxon

 

[SpikedBuffy]

Sarah Michelle Gellar

(can I use all five of my turn on her?)

James Marsters
Anthony Stewart Head
Alyson Hannigan
Nicholas Brendan

 

[Destructo Girl]

Amber Benson
James Marsters
Rebecca Rand Kirshner
Sarah Michelle Gellar
Anthony Stewart Head ("Percussion, dude....") 🙂

 

[WatcherWes]

Denisof
Whedon
Minear
Boreanaz
Mercedes McNab

 

[Xin Rong]

Does joss whedon count, if so obviously him but if not I'd have:
David Boreanaz
Amber Benson
Alyson Hannigan
Charisma Carpenter
Amy Acker and Eliza Dushku

I know there are six but I didnt want to leave any of them out lol

 

[Andy]

This is interesting.

James Marsters
Alexis Denisof
David Borneanaz
Alexa Dalvos
Tom Lenk

 

[celtic_beauty]

Sarah without a doubt
Seth (he's just too funny!)
Michelle (she's my age! we'd have fun!)
Anthony (helllloooooo sexy!)
David

runners up: emma, nicholas and james

 

[pyromaniac]

ELIZA DUSHKU
Amber Benson
James Marsters
Amy Acker
and......Alexis Denisof

 

[Wicked]

Ive already met:
Christian Kane
J August Richards
Andy Hallett (twice)
James Marsters
Mark Lutz (Groo)
Anthony Head
Robin Sachs
Danny strong
Harry Groener
George Hertzberg
Charisma Cartpenter
Amber Benson
Robin Atkin Downes (Machida from reptile boy)
Greg Vaughan (in reptile boy and Charmed)

so I would say:
Eliza Dushku
Seth Green
Emma Caulfield
Alyson Hannigan
Nicholas Brendon

 

[Cookie Dough]

So easy:

Sarah Michelle Gellar (my girl crush)
David Boreanaz (my celebrity crush)
Emma Caulfield
Tom Lenk
Amy Acker