Banned from Owning Music

Kean

Professional Bangel
Joined
Nov 13, 2007
Messages
11,945
Location
Ireland
Sineya
This story just popped up on Yahoo Ireland's homepage.


Everybody needs good neighbours. You don't have to be a follower of the most famous Australian soap in recent TV history to know that. Of course, the residents of Ramsay Street are forced to put up with some truly upsetting distractions, often involving serial villain Paul Robinson and a spectacularly bitter revenge plot.

Loud music is unlikely to send viewer ratings through the roof but spare a thought for people in real life who are tormented by incessant noise from next door. The latest example of this has emerged in Folkestone, where a man has had his stereo and CDs confiscated after breaking the terms of a noise abatement order.

Not only has the unnamed man, who terrorised residents of his block of flats, been deprived of the right to listen to music but his questionable tastes have also been exposed in the national media. Council officers say his "tiny collection" consisted almost entirely of "girly love songs", which were played at deafening volume, all night long.

"It must have been a nightmare for the other people living there," commented Liam Flannery, environmental health officer for Shepway District Council. "Unfortunately, the man concerned didn't have an extensive CD collection so it was the same few songs...over and over again."

"˜I'm Every Woman', a 1978 hit for Chaka Khan which was covered by Whitney Houston in 1993, was reportedly a particular favourite. A neighbour, who refused to be named, said: "It was horrible, truly horrible - nobody could get a decent night's sleep because this guy was blaring out love songs all through the night.

"God only knows where he got his musical taste from, but he needs to expand his horizons or he'll drive himself mad," they said after the council ruling, which bars the offender from owning any music. "We've got his stuff now and the warrant's open, so if he buys any more we'll take that too," insisted Flannery.

Source:Yahoo Ireland

As someone who has personal experience of having to live with noisy neighbours (My neighbour throws parties in her back garden at least three nights a week. We live in terraced houses so it is as good as the party being in my own room), I think this is horribly excessive. He can't own music? If he buys more it will taken from him?

What does everyone else think?
 
I was just thinking that when i was reading it 'surely he will just go and buy more or get a radio and listen to that'.
I have had problems with neighbours and music but the police and or council just give them warnings about it and they stop playing it so loud.
 
Is this real life? That is hilarious and ludicrous.

Fine the dude. Sentence him to jail if he can't pay. Make him buy some head phones. Get him a gorram musical mentor, but taking away someone's music ownership seems really excessive.

Please note that I too have experienced a noisy neighbor with poor musical taste but I still wouldn't have endorsed taking away their ability to have music.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
Z
zobothehobo
[No message]
Kean
Kean
Exactly. What happens if he gets creative and uses YouTube or something? Banned from the internet? Ridiculous.
Seriously, he cant own music?? Thats so riduclous! I live with very noisy people who never stop playing loud music but you can't really ban someone from owning music!
 
There is nothing wrong with that; a noise abatement order usually states you cannot play, or make (construction etc) noise above a certain level at a certain time of night. He did. They confiscated his stuff.

Seriously, look at the other examples from the article:

The edge of hell

We all like "˜Last Christmas', George Michael and Andrew Ridgeley's 1984 festive classic. But Sandyford resident Turner took this passion about 1,000 times too far, playing it non-stop for three hours from 1am back in May 2007. He was rewarded with a fine of £200 and the headline "˜Wham! ban for music fan' in the local paper.

Robbie inspires murder

Bulgarian Alexander Alexandrov was sent to prison for 16 years in 2009 after murdering his neighbour, Martin Kromov, who played Robbie Williams' "˜Angels' for a week at top volume. "I was in constant terror of his music. I could no longer think about anything but making him turn it off," the accused told the court.

Seems like it is a more common or, at least escalated occurrence.
 
I'm going to tell you guys a story. When the people who moved into the house across the street from my mom moved in, their oldest son was in 8th grade. His 9th grade year, he started a band with his friends. They practiced EVERY Friday and Saturday, most Sundays, and at least two or three times during the school week. On Fridays and Saturdays, they would practice from about noon to dinner time... and then they would throw a party. Sometimes it was high school kids, sometimes it was adults, friends of the family... but EVERY Friday and Saturday that house was FULL of people. And they would amp up their already REALLY loud instruments and play until about 2 AM. It was so loud, it shook my house. Well... it shook the house when they just practiced. It was so loud, it shook (just a tad) my aunt and uncle's house about four houses away. They could also hear the music crystal clear. We (as in pretty much the whole "upper" half of the neighborhood) called the cops every Friday and Saturday telling them the neighbors were too noisy... but nothing ever happened. (Which is one reason why I strongly believe the cops in my city steal our tax dollars and don't do shit.) As much as I hate my neighbors for doing that, I would never want to take away their right to listen to or play music. I love listening to and playing music! Music is awesome and kind of makes my life!

So I think this is really ridiculous. NO ONE should EVER not be allowed to listen to music.
 
O
Ollehh
ITA will the last line.
Seems fair. He was warned (people must have told him off before he got the order as all) and he still broke the noise abatement order. Dude doesn't deserve music. He could have gotten a iPod or mp3 like everyone else, or simply played low. He damaged his neighbours' calm, so he needed to be punished.

---------- Post added at 07:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:12 PM ----------

Robbie inspires murder

Bulgarian Alexander Alexandrov was sent to prison for 16 years in 2009 after murdering his neighbour, Martin Kromov, who played Robbie Williams' "˜Angels' for a week at top volume. "I was in constant terror of his music. I could no longer think about anything but making him turn it off," the accused told the court.

Seems fair. Loud constant noise was used as a torture method in a tv-show once. It was a experiment, to show people how easily someone could break. I think it might have been Gutanamo Bay related, maybe similar methods. Anyway, a lot of people had to quit during that test, they could take it. It sounded like this warning ring, like a boat leaving shore, warning for fire or war, I'm not sure. It was a loud single note. I imagine a week of the same song over and over again could have driven anyone over the edge. Specially if the cops were like zobothehobo's cops, not giving a damn.
 
I don't agree with the taking away music rights lol....give him headphones or something 😛

But the thing is, and why you have to (old hippy alert) question everything, you don't have the full story.

What if he was given several warnings, and what if after the warnings they fined him, then after that they sentenced him to a three-day jail term and he still continued.

What if no matter what they did at midnight every night he blared those love songs just to frustrate his neighbors? It could have not been his enjoyment of music that was the problem but his using said music as a tool in a previous squabble. What better way to get vengeance against a neighbor than to keep him up and drive him crazy with the same intolerable song every night for hours on end.
 
I don't agree with the taking away music rights lol....give him headphones or something 😛

Thing is, he was told to keep it down, and he didn't. What's the other option? Fine him until he has to sell everything he owns, including the CDs, so he'll keep quiet? Gluing headphones to his head so he got the message?

Dude's a jerk, who got enough warning.
 
I don't even understand how they could possibly enforce a ban on listening to music. Does he have someone following him around 24 hours a day? Or, like someone mentioned earlier, how are they going to stop him from going online to listen to music? Do they search his house every night before he goes to bed?
 
Last edited:
Skanky Vamp
Skanky Vamp
they could van gogh him!!
I don't even understand how they could possibly enforce an a ban on listening to music. Does he have someone following him around 24 hours a day? Or, like someone mentioned earlier, how are they going to stop him from going online to listen to music? Do they search his house every night before he goes to bed?

I doubt that, but if it's proven he's listening to music, I hope he gets jail-time. Maybe the threat of jail is suppose to keep in in line?
 
That story made me laugh a little, blasting girly love songs over and over all night? Silly silly man.

I completely understand why they would confiscate the music as he clearly broke the noise abatement order several times and I do think he should have been reprimanded since he continued to do so.

Taking away his right to own music is just as silly as him playing sappy love songs all night long. How on earth would the regulate that?
 
I'm betting that two witnessess saying "He was playing music" would be enough, and it's off to the big house.

True, I wonder how long he would be in jail, if it ever went that far.

I'm betting it must be pretty frustrating being one of the police officers who have to deal with this guy. This guy is wasting the police and council officers time and is wasting tax payers money...they should be out dealing with more serious issues.
 
There is no way they can tell this guy he can't own any music. WTF. LOL That is so rediculous I don't even know what else to say!
Yes, it sucks when you have neighbors who refuse to respect your ears and keep their noise level to a minimum, but all they can do is fine them for noise polution and/or evict them, so they become someone else's problem.
 
Z
zobothehobo
[No message]
T
TheFirstSlayer
[No message]
That's still no excuse. Doesn't mean he should make his problems everyone elses' problems. Specially when he could use headphones.

Well, I was more thinking like what if he can't use headphones or something. Headphones are such an obvious and convenient solution, it makes me wonder if there was some reason he couldn't get them. Having to listen to music that loudly in his own house could have damaged his hearing as well. At the same time, he did receive multiple warnings. It's just a weird situation all around. Personally, I think taking away his CDs is a little much, reminds me of the way parents deal with children. 😀 Just fine him or something instead.
 
Back
Top Bottom