Best Halloween Episode?

[VisionGirl]

Halloween! Life of the Party is awesome too; Fear, Itself is funny, but it got old after I watched it about four times in a row (That's LOGO's fault!).

Aargh, I hate that about LOGO! I get so frustrated when I can't watch Buffy/Angel downloaded from Netflix on my BluRay player (because my brats are watching TV usually LOL), but the only eps on LOGO are ones that I've already seen in my current watching, and are replayed dozens of times before moving on!

 

[Thursday]

I've never seen "Life of the Party," and I don't like "All the Way" (except for Anya being dressed up like a "Charlie"). Choosing between Halloween and Fear, Itself is hard as I really enjoy both episodes.

But, I picked Fear, Itself. Whereas Halloween was just funny character development, Fear, Itself did all that and was creepy (which is kind of something I want from a Halloween episode).

 

[MinwaraYana]

"Halloween"! It's funny and it's interesting when they're like what they dressed. I love Ghost Willow and Soldier Xander. 😀 Cordelia was funny too. I like "Fear, Itself" too, but the only 10/10 moment is the Gachnar scene.

 

[Karol]

Voted Halloween, it´s my favorite by far. I think Fear Itself was fun, specially Anya with the Bunny costume, but Halloween was great with Ethan! I like how they used this episode to explain all Xander's knowledge of army stuff lol

Life of the Party is also nice and funny, but the giant Lorne was kind of lame >.< I like the reactions the character have o/

All the Way is Halloween episode? OK, I need to watch Season 6 again.

 

[Bluebird]

Life of the Party doesn't feel very Halloweeny but it's hilarious so it wins.

 

[Wild At Heart]

Halloween for sure. It's just a classic.

 

[Tasha]

I voted 'Halloween' ! It never gets boring, it's the best imo 🙂

 

[Secret Slayer]

There all fab but i voted for halloween

 

[urbanlegend23]

Fear, Itself without a doubt! Tucker Gates did a beautiful job with the direction, the episode had a neat MOTW and was character-based too. And actually pretty spooky in parts. This is one of my favourites of season 4.

I like Halloween, but I find it a bit overrated.

My order would be:

1. Fear, Itself
2. Life of the Party
3. Halloween
4. All the Way