Best Singer in OMWF

Best singer in Once More With Feeling

  • Sarah

    Votes: 5 4.3%

  • Anthony

    Votes: 55 47.8%

  • James

    Votes: 13 11.3%

  • Nicholas

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Michelle

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Amber

    Votes: 41 35.7%

  • Alyson

    Votes: 1 0.9%
  • Total voters
    115
Another vote for Amber, although Hinton Battle carries the whole show and if there was a place to vote for him, I would have picked him.
 
Amber and Anthony I think were by far the best but I had to pick one so I went with Amber. In a previous episode where they see Giles singing Blue Eyes was awesome though
 
iShower4free said:
Amber and Anthony I think were by far the best but I had to pick one so I went with Amber. In a previous episode where they see Giles singing Blue Eyes was awesome though
Click to expand...

Oh don't forget when Giles sang Freebird. I pretty much melted when he sang that one 😛
 
Hm, hard, hard choice to make...
Especially as the whole singing goes along with the acting...and when it comes to that during the songs, no one can beat Sarah.
But closing the eyes and only listening to the voices I gotta say...James. Love that deep, raspy voice! 🙂
 
I find it interesting that Emma was the one who got the nod to do further singing in later episodes but she isn't even on the list. Of the ones on the list, I thought Anthony and Amber were good but Amber's voice seemed to gain altitude effortlessly whereas Anthony's voice showed a great deal of effort.
 
If you think Ambers range is was a bit high you would be right her sond The one I need from a movie she did shows her range better

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YN0LAPnmJVE"]The One I Need - Amber Benson & James Saez - YouTube[/ame]
 
I'd pick Anthony and Amber as the best singers but I guess they have an infair advantage given that they're both trained. James has a good voice, very smooth. Sarah was very impressive but it is obvious that she's not a trained singer. That being said, she's still great. Emma and Nick were both impressive too, again it's easy to tell they're not natural singers.

In the end I think everyone did a great job with the musical.
 
Amber is naturally my favorite. Emma's voice was a pleasant surprise though, some of her bits in I'll Never Tell are downright lovely IMO.
 
Definitely Anthony and Amber, and their duet/reprise is one of the episode's most haunting moments.

If you haven't seen it, you should look up the video on YouTube of the two of them doing Rocky Horror songs in, I think, some kind of benefit concert. He sings Frank and she sings Janet.
 
The most obvious are Amber and Anthony, they can really sing. I think Ambers voice is so pretty, but Sarah for someone who's not really a singer like that did really good. She has a cute little voice. And James his voice is sexy (you can tell he kept the accent when he was singing that's what made it better to me) I love it.
 
Amber for me. "Under Your Spell" makes me melt. That song is just so romantic, and Amber's voice works perfectly in it. Anthony was also fantastic, of course. Anthony and Amber's duet, "Under Your Spell/Standing (Reprise)," was just heavenly. And I do have to give major props to Sarah. For someone who had never sung before, she was absolutely fantastic. I was so impressed with her. But then again, Sarah's just awesome. So Amber, Anthony, and Sarah are my faves. 🙂
 
Did anyone consider Sweet, the demon played by Hinton Battle? His acting, dancing, singing and spoken voice make his performance the best of any on any TV program anytime, anywhere.

Second to that was Amber, whose effortless highs were great. I thought Anthony's voice was good but always sounded strained. And no votes for Michelle's tiny little voice? It seemed perfect for her character.
 
Hard decision

There are two that I think are equally great which is Tara and Anya but on terms of performance and I think delivered the most was Anya but Tara I'll admit did surprise me with her voice.
I found it hard to believe that Dawn really was singing and I would have liked Spike to sing Elton John's Don't let the sun go down on me.
 
Why isn't Emma on the poll for best singer in OMWF?

Why isn't Emma Caufield (actress who played Anya) on the poll? I thought she was the best singer in the episode despite me not being an Anya fan.
 
I could not disagree more... she was average at best, Tara and Giles out sing her by miles, even Gile's, Anya was just better than Buffy/Willow etc who were all awful 🙂
 
Anthony. Amber and James are close seconds. I wasn't too keen on Sarah's and I thought Michelle's miming was quite bad.
 
All of them had wonderful voices but when I heard Anthony's voice for the first time prior to this back in season 4 I was just wowed. His voice is amazing.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom