Biggest Buffy Scare?

[Slayerfest03]

i think that Dead things in season 6 was really freaky and conversations with dead people, the scenes with Dawn reminded me of the Exorcist

 

[Michelle]

Hush when Olivola looked out the window. Ans in Conversations with Dead ppl in Dawns like whole scene.

 

[Lily]

the whole of Hush
killed by death and the creepy fish monsters in Go Fish (i have water fear)

 

[Spike]

Hush ( ow was anyone not freaked by this ep)
the killed by death guy whos name i know i cant spell so i aint even gonna trie.
the clown that chased Xander in Nightmares (i have clown fear)

 

[Nightspirit]

The Gentlemen!! they were the worst. Them and Der Kindestod.

 

[Buffy16Angel]

Originally posted by desolate_soul
Hush ( ow was anyone not freaked by this ep)
the killed by death guy whos name i know i cant spell so i aint even gonna trie.
the clown that chased Xander in Nightmares (i have clown fear)

The clown was scary. I hate clowns.

 

[Lilah]

I ike Clowns!!!

 

[dyingangel]

I didn't find the gentlemen that scary, but i thought that a pretty freaking scary moment was when Dawn was in the house and , and she was screaming, then she saw Joyce, ooh that was good...

 

[Dizzy]

Hands down the Gentlemen! Very scary!!

 

[Jacklyn]

I have to go with the consensus...The gentlemen and gnarl were by far the scariest creatures ever on BTVS!!!

 

[Buffy16Angel]

Originally posted by Buffster6
Hands down the Gentlemen! Very scary!!

The Gentleman was scary!

 

[slayerangel]

The Gentlemen and the Kindestod were all scary.

 

[Spike]

Seeing Oz not only first thing in the morning but without shirt on *shuders*.

 

[Tyra]

Re: it's all fun and games until someone gets stabbed to death...

Originally posted by WyrdDemonHunter
Without a doubt, the scenes in 7x16 Storyteller where we get to see inside Andrew's mind...

Previously, we've heard Andrew speak in a manner that indicates he wasn't very connected to reality. But to actually see how his mind worked, and then to think, "until recently, this person was allowed to roam freely in the world"... that's unsettling.

Especially when you consider that people like Andrew are only the tip of the iceberg. I mean, for the most part he walks and talks like your average geek-on-the-street with limited social skills, but he's really a murderer with thought disorders. What about all those people just dumped out into the world from mental institutions because of overcrowding and budget issues?

Aside from Andrew's brain, the entire episode of "Passion" in S2 with the Angelus voice-over has always totally creeped me out (which is probably why I think it's the best BtVS episode ever). 🙂

And yes, the Gentlemen, Gnarl, and Das Kindertot, too.

 

[Willow's Girl]

The Gentlemen scare me. The bit with Olivia looking out of the window always makes me jump.

 

[DarkFaith]

The Gentlemen and the Dawn scenes from Conversations With Dead People. Argh!!

 

[BuffyUKer]

i think the bit wneh the gentelmen were handing over the scalple to one another with their BIG grins weas the creepyes bit of the epi... the scor gave the epi that extra scare boost. with out it, it would not have been half as scarey!

 

[polo_from_BTY]

the only demons that have EVER scared me in Buffy are pretty spaced out..

1. The Gentlemen (S4)
2. Gnarl (S7)
3. Der Kinderstod (S1)

 

[DáNió]

The Gentlemen
Gnarl

 

[Lilah]

Originally posted by polo_from_BTY
the only demons that have EVER scared me in Buffy are pretty spaced out..

1. The Gentlemen (S4)
2. Gnarl (S7)
3. Der Kinderstod (S1)

Der Kindestod was from Season 2, they are the same demons which have scared me!!!