I gave it 5 stars, they're my favorite couple, even more than I loved Buffy with Angel. I also loved watching their relationship in season 6, it was abusive at times but how could it not be, she was in a state of depression and self loathing all season, he was soulless and feeling used. I thought the sex scenes were hot, especially Smashed and some stuff in Dead Things, and it wasn't all about sex. They both felt like outsiders, they understood each other in ways the scoobies didn't at the time, she shared things with him she couldn't tell other people. Like at the end of Flooded when Buffy says she isn't into crowds Spike agrees neither is he, they both feel kind of alone.