Well I'm not sure about the whole 'Goth' look, why do you all assume she'd have to look Goth in order to be a rebel. Why can't she dress like a normal 16 year-old, but still get herself into all sorts of rebellious activities. Plus I don't know about Dawn getting rebellious? I mean seriously, any guy who tries to shock her in some way is in for a big surprise. Whats he gonna do to shock her? Light a joint? Whoop-de-doo!! This is a girl who has been captured by vampires, killed a vampire, made out with a vampire, watched her sister jump off a tower, watch her sister come back to life, Dawn herself actually brought her mom back albeit briefly, she's been captured and smacked around by an angry and insane hellgod, so really, I don't think there is much some 'normal' guy could do to impress or shock her.