Carrie or Bo?

Who should win American Idol 4?

  • Bo Bice

    Votes: 5 45.5%

  • Carrie Underwood

    Votes: 6 54.5%
  • Total voters
    11
B

buffetofsporks

Sir Gaga
Joined
May 23, 2005
Messages
515
Age
37
Location
Georgia
I did a search and didn't see anything on the subject. Anyways, who's it gonna be? With the season finale of American Idol airing in minutes, who should take the tital? Personally, I don't think either deserve it. Vonzell should've at least made it to the final two, but I guess that's out of the question. Anyways, here's where we make our predictions. Right now, between the two, I'm rooting for Carrie only because Bo gets on my nerves and needs to take a shower or something. Hmm ...

And this isn't an idol bashing thread, either. All haters can ... hate somewhere else. Nah, I don't care. Whateva.
 
Okay, I've got my Bud... My TV is up and running... I'm pumped... And it's all about CARRIE baby! She has a killer voice... I love Bo too... But he'd be way better in a band, and doesn't seem like a solo-ist... So check my sig... Carrie all the way!
 
C
charmingangelC
Carrie rules! :)
Yea... I don't live in America so I know nothing about either of them.. But, I voted Carrie, just to be all supportive and stuff, since my girlfriend is apparently crazy about that girl... heh.
 
A
Amber Benson
See? That's why I love you ;)
They were the two I'd been pulling for from the beginning so I don't really care who wins because I like them both. Thank goodness Vonzell didn't make it, she was really pitchy in the lower register and it drove me up the wall.
 
*holds up a Bo poster* Bo fo sho! Hmm. Looks like I'm the only Bo fan so far! Carrie's got a killer voice, but I'm not much of a country fan. Bo's sexy in so many ways! But one word sums it all up. Rocker!
 
B
Beer_Nut
Actually I voted for Bo, but I like them both.
Bo should win. Carrie has an amazing voice, but she can't perform. she tries, but she just can't do it so she gets really boring to watch. personally i think that Constantine should have been in the top two (i wanted him to win, and Bo get second)......
 
I agree. I think Constantine should've won. If I had my pick, it would've came down between him and Nadia but yeah ... not gonna happen. Anyways, Bo's in the lead, now.
 
I also thought Constantine should have won, but he got extremely cocky... Blah no thanks... And Bo... He cannot move without that damn mic-stand... I mean COMEON... Carrie atleast tries now, and she does have some rhythm... Unlike Bo when he's standless... And, I think Carrie would be a far better investment for the record company... I think Bo would be another Justin... Hot for a bit, then dies off... So I'm still with the CARRIE LOVE!!!
 
I'm with Carrie all the way!!! Not big of country really but her voice is so beautiful. I wish I could sing like that! And Bo's hair. Has to be cut! I can't stand guys that have hair that long. Carrie has moves when she is on stage but Bo just kinda stand around. Plus Carrie is really pretty!
-Love Leslie::heart::
 
I voted for Carrie. It's undeniable that both have massive amounts of talent, stage presense, and style. The reason I voted for Carrie is because of Bo's criminal record. It was announced a long time ago about Bo's criminal record, like Scott Savol's, where he beat his girlfriend to a bloody pulp and she called the cops. Someone who can abuse women is not an Idol and that what kept him from my vote.
 
I picked Carrie, of course! She rules! My brother was watching last night's show with me and he turns to me and goes, "She's hot and her voice rocks. Vote for her!"

I really hope she wins!

*runs back to the couch as the commercial ends*
 
Hero said:
I voted for Carrie. It's undeniable that both have massive amounts of talent, stage presense, and style. The reason I voted for Carrie is because of Bo's criminal record. It was announced a long time ago about Bo's criminal record, like Scott Savol's, where he beat his girlfriend to a bloody pulp and she called the cops. Someone who can abuse women is not an Idol and that what kept him from my vote.
Click to expand...

Yea definately... It's kinda hypocritical... I can't remember her name, but that one woman from the first season was kicked off the show because she posed for nude photos before, and then season 2 (I believe) one guy was kicked off for the same thing that both Scott and Bo did... What's up with that?
 
Amber Benson said:
Yea definately... It's kinda hypocritical... I can't remember her name, but that one woman from the first season was kicked off the show because she posed for nude photos before, and then season 2 (I believe) one guy was kicked off for the same thing that both Scott and Bo did... What's up with that?
Click to expand...
Coery Clark is the guy you're thinking of, I believe. He didn't disclose his arrest record to the producers like Bo and Scott did, so he was kicked off. I can't bring myself to get angry about that because he accused Paula of having an affair with him, something I don't believe.
 
This is great for Carrie, as I said before I liked them both so I am happy at the ending and will buy both their albums when they come out.

BTW, Bo was not arrested for abuse he was arrested for drug possession. Only Scott was arrested for abuse.
 
Oh, wow, I'm so happy for Carrie! It was really sweet when she brought her mom up on stage! I love Carrie. Good for her! She's really talented and she deserves it.
 
I am not an Amercian Idol fan but I had to watch and see who won. Carrie and Bo were both terrific but I am glad that Carrie won. She has an amazing voice!!
 
Beer Nut - really? i could have sworn it was both of them. someone who does/did drugs is not an Idol.

The girl you're talking about was actually during season 2. The big black girl? Frenchie Davis. One of my top favorites. She did Rent for like 2 years on Broadway, I think, and now she's doing another Broadway thing I just can't remember what.

Mikalah last night.... Ah.... I love her. I talked to her on the phone and got an autograph. My favorite Idol ever, even though everyone hates her.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom