Cordelia's new reality in Birthday

Pagan

Potential
Joined
Dec 6, 2004
Messages
153
Has it ever occurred to anyone that the reality Skip showed Cordy in Birthday may have been the "real" reality? The one that was supposed to have occurred?

I'll explain what i mean. We know that much of what has happened to Cordelia this last few years has been down to manipulations by Jasmine. She needed Cordy to give birth to her new physical form and so Jasmine arranged for her and the others to all play their parts in the process.

The point where these manipulations began has never been made clear. For all we know Jasmine has arranged everything from Darla being sired to Cordy herself being born. It is certainly possible that she had been planning this for centuries. She has existed from the dawn of time after all.

However lets assume that it doesn't go back quite as far as that and that Jasmine only started using Team Angel fairly recently, say since Angel moved to L.A. for the sake of a starting point. This could easily have been the time when Jasmine noticed Angel and realised she could use him to arrange her rebirth into the world.

So at that point she knew that she needed a "mother", somebody that could be easily convinced to become a part of Angel's life. Then what happens? The Powers send Angel on his first mission that just happens to include him going to a party where an old friend is also present. This must have seemed like a gift to Jasmine. Immediately she steps in to make certain that Cordy and Angel cross paths at the party.

This is the point where destiny changes for the first time i believe and it is Skip who pointed that out to me. We already knew that Jasmine had manipulated things but now we know where from, at least in Cordy's case.

In Birthday Skip tells Cordy that she is living the wrong life, that her Destiny was to be the star she had always dreamed of being, not a demon hunter. This he shows her by bringing up an image of the party from City of. He demonstrates how, instead of bumping into Angel that night, she was meant to have met the guy who would have made her television career explode and turned her into a star. It was Jasmine's first manipulation of Cordy's life that altered this and changed the destiny she was meant for.

Now of course we all know that Skip was working for Jasmine, even at this point, and that this was all a further manipulation in order to get Cordy to realise that she HAD to keep the visions and therefore accept that demonic alterations to herself to survive them were needed (or more truthfully that demonic alterations that would make her the perfect vessel for Jasmine to use were needed).

That doesn't change the fact that this could all still have been true though. In fact it just makes it more likely as Jasmine would know better than anyone what Cordelia had really been destined for before she altered things. The alternate reality that we saw in Birthday wasn't just some fabrication that Skip made up, it was the life that Cordelia and the others would have lived if Jasmine hadn't interfered.

So question is, given what we saw, do you think that Jasmine actually did Team Angel a favour in using them. Is the life that they ended up with any worse than the lives they would have lived if she had left them alone?
 
Good Question! And yes I think that Jasmine, in the end, did them a favor. We all know that they survive the apocalypse of season 4 and without Jasmine's interference they wouldn't have all been brought together to do good. So many more people would have died if Angel had received the visions from Doyle because Angel wouldn't have been there to save them. Sure Wes & Gunn are strong, but they're not vampires.
 
Pagan said:
So question is, given what we saw, do you think that Jasmine actually did Team Angel a favour in using them. Is the life that they ended up with any worse than the lives they would have lived if she had left them alone?

that's a very interesting point, i really never thought of it this way before.
seems to me that in light of everything that happened, she certainly did them a favor, but the question that rises here is if she could really predict all of that, couldn't she also predict they would eventually turn on her? or can she really see everyone's destiny but her own?
what she did to team angel - the favor she did - she actually united them, and that union was the cause for her eventual downfall, so isn't that kinda ironic, it makes me think that she either wasn't too careful or there is simply something else to it (which i will refer to later on). like you said, we really can't tell when exactly she interfered in their lives, but if she could see so many steps ahead, couldn't she see this?
"birthday" bears certain similarities to "the wish" in many ways (except excuse me for saying it could never beat that), and to "normal again" (or that 😉 ). in the end, the three of them make us question what is the true reality? did some being manipulate everything or was it something tiny that we did that changed things, opened a doorway to an alternate universe and sucked everything in it and it became our lives. i think "birthday" is just another attempt to explain that. it really all depends how you look at it.
in jasmine's case, it only complicates matters. like i said, wouldn't she know they would betray her? well, assuming that we take the other option, that it wasn't her manipulation, but natural course of events that she took advantage on - maybe she did know? maybe she just came to offer people a choice, the way that cordelia was offered a choice. she offered them their perfect world, but on the other hand if they wanted to, if they were willing to sacrifice, they could choose the alternate reality, the imperfect one. maybe she knew she would be overthrown but she still wanted this chance. but really, wouldn't that make her good?...
 
That whole idea of alternate realities is so fascinating, and if you incorporate it into your Buffyverse view, a lot of the stuff that seemed hard to explain away, becomes all at once understandable.

For example there's the Normal Again thing Wicca mentioned. If you think of insane Buffy's world as an alternate reality, rather than a hallucination it starts to make another kind of sense. Or what about vengence demons? Think of them as creating alternate realities to suck energy from, rather than manipulating this one, and you can explain away how these creatures could do what they do, and still allow our own personal mundane realities to exist.

In the case of Jasmine, I always wondered how she could possibly know that tweaking this here, or that there, could without error create such and such a result.

You can reason that away if you consider the possibility that all possible realities already exist for viewing by a being such as Jasmine.

So which is the true reality, the core reality? I'm going to choose to believe it's the one Jasmine wanted to manipulate. She would have an idea of what would happen if such and such were the case, under such and such a circumstance from viewing alternate realities, but she would want to manipulate things at the source. At the core.
 
The way i see it is that Jasmine couldn't really predict the future, she didn't know exactly what each manipulation was going to lead to, all she knew was what she needed to happen in the end and therefore she just kept tweaking events until everyone and everything she needed was in the right place at the right time.

For example she didn't know for certain that Cordy would decide to join with Angel just because she brought them together at the party. Had that not worked she would have tried something else. Maybe she did in fact, maybe Jasmine was the reason that Russell noticed Cordy and sent for her to come to his home, thus bringing Angel and Cordy back together a second time. Otherwise Cordy being the girl that was there that night would have been an incredible coincidence don't you think?

Of course after Jasmine left the higher planes inside Cordy she left behind the ability to manipulate with that amount of success and so her plans were constantly changing due to not being able to see the big picture anymore. That is why she ultimately lost to Angel, because she gave up her omnipotence and became much less powerful once on earth. A fact she probably wasn't prepared for.
 
Thanks for that. I have to admit, I like your explanation better as an interpretation of the text.

I still like mine as an interpretation beyond the text though, because it creates all kinds of interesting possibilities.
 
That is a very interesting point. I am beginning to wonder if Cordy and Angel were really destined to meet that the party in the first episode. It is interesting to think that the "Birthday" reality was the actual reality that Cordelia was supposed to be living.

I agree that thinking of alternate realities gives a lot more room for explaining things in the buffyverse.
 
Wow, you must think a lot! I never even thought of that.

To what Cordelia saw with Angel and Wesley not having an arm.... then with Cordelia as part of the team....Jasmine did them a huge favor in interfering....but that should have been it. Being reborn? Just not cool. : /
 
The point where these manipulations began has never been made clear. For all we know Jasmine has arranged everything from Darla being sired to Cordy herself being born. It is certainly possible that she had been planning this for centuries. She has existed from the dawn of time after all.

Well we know jasmine started manipulating things long before cordy went to that party because it was the end of series 2 of angel when fred left Pylea and we know she was there for 5 years and 5 years before this episode is approximately when cordy first found out about vampires (i.e. last ep of series 1) therefore we know its at least from this point is where jasmine started manipulations and plus i got he impression that doye was never meant to die in hero, as we know cordy was manouvered into the point where she could get visions, its my own personal theory that jasmine sent doyle the vision about the 1/2 demon and 1/2 humans that needed help which means that doyle would have still been around so angel wouldn't have gone crazy and then theres the shansu prophecies and i doubt angel could have fulfilled them without his sanity or at least lack of complete insanity also we know visions need love to be passed on as skip told us in (i think the ep was) birthday girl then again he could have been lying as he was in on the whole plan as a merc.

In conclusion i dont think the reaity skip showed cordy was the real reality because it just sucked... and also we also know from the episode of buffy in series 6 that cordy and angel and every other buffyverse character weren't real anyway therefore the truely real reality is our reality and buffy's reality is more of a solipcist or descartes third wave of doubt reality which is kind of depressing
 
The reality that skip showed cordy according to the commentary on that ep i'm told is to show you to viewer, and Cordy that life without Angel having her by his side to help him keep in touch with his human side sucked.
No one to guide him with the visions made his burden hard hence his inability to deal with them.

So she is manipulated by the events to make the ultimate sacrifice and take them off him so she can help Angel .

Jasmine i reckon just took advantage of the situations by manipulating certain events in Cordys Life and possibly the others ie Doyle having that vision that led to his death, so that she would come into this world via Conner and Cordy.

I wouldn't be surprised if she had something to do wiht Conner 's conception, maybe influencing both Angel and Darla's act bet the sheets?
 
Back
Top Bottom