There is no bad in this episode! This one is about truth and lies, how we can distinguish between them and why we lie to ourselves and others and how we are programmed to believe certain things. The First has told it's tales to the scoobies and now they had to discern the truth of them. Dawn is convinced she was told the truth, because she is programmed to believe her mother wouldn't lie to her, whereas Willow, Xander and Buffy all need more proof.
The scene between Buffy and Spike in Xander's apartment is great. Spike shows concern that she had to kill someone she'd known. Buffy doesn't reveal the whole truth to Spike about Holden, and Spike doesn't tell Buffy he's been killing again, though we the audience have seen it happen.
Anya and Spike together have great chemistry and are fun. Spike grabbing her arm is really threatening, but once Anya lies to him about her reasons for being there he becomes almost scared of her. I do like that Anya calls him William, though I'm not really sure why.
Buffy as The First confronting Spike is so disorientating, not only for Spike. He doesn't understand what's happening and neither do we. It's quite chilling when First/Buffy says 'There's my guy'.
Love the scene between Buffy and Spike in his bedroom. He doesn't believe he can kill, he accuses Buffy of jealousy, he's angry she can't see that it's the soul, not the chip that stops him killing, and he got the soul for her. He's adamant he has not tasted human blood. Buffy doesn't know what to believe and her response to the accusation of jealousy seems a bit weak 'Don't flatter yourself' 🙂 It's a beautiful scene, with neither of them knowing the truth, but by the end they both need to find proof.
Aimee Mann plays Pavlovs Bells at the Bronze, a comment on the theme that we are all programmed to react to certain stimulus in certain ways, was nicely used to intercut with the fight Spike has on the balcony. I don't think this is just about the trigger, but also that he has been programmed over the last few years to fight his own kind. He earlier denied the chip played any part in his present state, but I think this scene shows that to be another lie (rationalisation?)
Spike eventually remembers the truth, although it really isn't, and tells Buffy that she was right and he is killing again. It's the taste of Buffy's blood that forces him to remember everything he's done. Buffy realises there is something else going on here, and this truth is actually only partly true. Spike accepts his punishment but Buffy understands now that he was being used and had no choice in his actions.
We're left with another lie, when we see a Bringer surely killing Giles. Great ending, leaving the audience shocked and unsure of what's to become of our Watcher.
Loved this episode, it's so disorientating, we don't know the truth of anything. It also shows that Spike does feel guilt about what he's done. He's horrified at killing these people and he would readill accept death as his punishment.
Once again Xander stands out as the MVS (most valuable scoobie), he's having a great S7 so far. He's great with Buffy and Anya, smart and funny and kind. He's being 'objective' guy, so mature in his suit, carrying his briefcase, but he's absolutely at his best when he's trying to stop Spike leave and gets punched in the face 🙂