~*Eric's Graphic Battle Sign Ups*~

I am sorry to say, SpuffyIsEternal is leaving us this round!

Jade In The Sky:: 15
Kryptonite:: 15
Lyri:: 19
evo:: 17
SpuffyisEternal:: 14


Judge Comments:::

XDruX:
Jade In The Sky-

7/10
Nice composition. I like the colours but sometimes it's a bit too messy like the face of David in the middle

Kryptonite-

5/10
It's nice but a bit too simple. Maybe if the stars were not purple/pink it would have brought more life to that.

Lyri-

9/10
Very Nice. I like the colour and the composition of it.
The line under the little pictures gives movement to the banner. My only reservation: if these little pictures were different from the main ones, it would have been better.

evo-

8/10
Nice. The pictures are well chosen. The colours are also nice. But the grey line at the bottom is a bit too large.

SpuffyIsEternal-

6/10
Nice banner. The colours make me think of a ghost series, like the one with Faith. Nevertheless the composition is a bit too common.



spuffy:
Kryptonite::

10/10 Perfect banner. Not crowded, fantastic composion, great picture quality.

Jade In The Sky::

8/10 It has a good concept but I feel that the filters you used effected the picture quality. I would have wanted it to look a bit more detailed.

Lyri::

10/10 A classic idea with new inventions, I like it alot especially the colours.

evo::

9/10 I like the colours in here too, I like the Black and White picture and the frame around it but I fear that it lacks something. The little glow you used makes the picture looks brilliant.

SpuffyisEternal::

8/10 It's a beautiful banner but I'm sorry I must say that there's nothing creative about it. The pictures quality are again not so good. The writing in the middle is my favourite thing in this piece though.​


NEXT ROUND WILL BE POSTED TOMORROW!!!​
 
^It's very confusing!! There are originally supposed to be 3 judges! But only 2 people signed up to be a judge... So I just included myself as a judge! But then, during the middle of this round, somebody requested to be a judge... So I let XDruX in and I took myself out... So, we have XDruX, spuffy, and :😛erfect Illusion:: as judges... But :😛erfect Illusion:: never turned in her judge comments... So, I just went on without those judge comments... That is why we only have 2 sets of judge comments this round, instead of 3... Do you get it???

The judges of the next round are going to be:: (These are the judges for the rest of the competition!)
XDruX
spuffy
:😛erfect Illusion::
 
J
Jade In The Sky
Thanks. :) I figured out about the third judge comments that were missing, I wanted to know what the next round will be like :)
X
XDruX
Oh my, I didn't know you left . Thanks again!
I hope you guys won't hate but remember this competition is about learning and realizing what works and what not. We're sad that contestants are leaving but only one will win in the end but yet again it is not the point.
 
🙁 I wish everyone else good luck...it sucks that I have to work with paintshop because I could probably do more with photoshop...🙁 oh well...
 
The Chosen
The Chosen
you did good. don't worry. :)
when's the next challenge going to be posted? you said the next round would be posted 'tomorrow' that was Wednesday.
 
Yeah, sorry guys! Here is the next round::


Start Date: June 8, 2007
End Date: June 15, 2007
Graphic: Wallpaper
Who of: Alyson Hannigan
Text: whatever you want
Colors: whatever you want
 
Ok guys, later today I am going to send the judges a PM so they can judge! I can't do it right now cause I have to be somewhere... I just had to get on here for a sec and let ya'll know that! So when I get back, I will send them a PM!
 
Oh yeah! Sorry I didn't post them earlier... I forgot! lol! Here they are::

Lyri::
alyson.jpg


evo::
untitled4fo0.jpg


Jade in the Sky::
alyson_round3.jpg


Kryptonite::
haniganwallpaper_060807.jpg
 
wow, all the entries look amazing!! i'm really nervous now!! lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom