Hmmm, toughie, its gotta be Lindsey though. I absolutly loved W & H at first, with Holland the big boss(sinister looking creep that he was)
and Lindsey and lilahs almost sibling rivalry. But Lindsey was such an interesting character, he didnt seem evil, just very selfish. But from young hotshot lawyer to in love with Darla to wannabe bad ass in s5, Lindsey brought alot to the show.
Lilah on the other hand just seemed bland and evil.