Been a long time since I posted in this thread of mine, but Im lovin all the legitamate forshadowing and the faux forshadowing that you guys are comin up with! 🙂
I dont think this one has been said before, I looked at all the posts again but really just skimmed. In Real Me, when Willow is hugging Tara she says "Your one of the good guys now" and Tara gets that look on her face, foreshadowing the fact that she is keeping a secret, that she thinks she is a demon. Which is also foreshadowed in the season 4 episode, Goodbye Iowa, when they do that spell and Tara delibrately screws it up.
In Bad Eggs, Buffy and Angel are kissing in the graveyard, the camera pans to the tombstone that sez "In Loving Memory" foreshadowing the disintigration of their relationship in Innocence.
Ofcourse everything but the cheese man is suppose to be meaningfull in Restless, I was thinkin about that a little bit the other day and this is what I came up with. In Xander's dream his father sez to him "What are you ashamed of us?" etc. In Hells Bells he leaves Anya at the alter partly because he is scared he will be a bad husband like his father.
In Storyteller when Andrew is recording Spike he is tryin to act all intimidating for the camera like in Giles dream in Restless, when he is doin all his funny poses for the camera.
I read these ones somewhere, in Buffy's dream she meets the first slayer in the desert, she is in the same desert again in Get It Done, also when Buffy thinks she wakes up in her dream she sees the first slayer chained to the celling, and again in Get It Done we learn that the shadowmen made the first slayer while chaining her to the earth.