Good & Evil

Nikkolas

Glory/Dawn Shipper.......
Joined
Jul 5, 2008
Messages
237
Age
37
Location
Fort Worth, TX
Well yes this will be subjective. That's the point.
This topic is to number the heroes and villains of Buffy and Angel on a Good-o-meter and Evil-o-meter.

For good people, the ranking goes 1-10 with 1 being they're really not that heroic but they're not evil either and 10 being they hardly ever did anything wrong in their life and only did noble things.
0 would then be characters who blur the edge and did both good and evil in proportion to each other.
Finally badness is ranked from -1 to -10 with -1 being they're not pleasant and they did a few bad things and -10 being SATAN. But you get the point.

In case people need a few examples:
Tara would be a 9 or 10 for me. The only wrong thing she ever did was a spell to try and make sure her friends didn't reject her back to an abusive, exist family. Beside that she was loving and supportive of everyone.

Caleb would be a -9 or 10 because he was the only human vessel on Earth who was so malevolent that he could merge with the origin of evil itself.

Get the idea?

What I'm really interested in is the characters who are less simple, though. Like Lindsey, pre-soul Spike and any other characters who did both good and evil and what different people will score them as.
Obviously we all will rank them different as we all have different notions of good and evil and that's what I'm really curious about.

I think i explained this well...and I think it could be very interesting.
 
Well, I'll start it off with the big one then - Jasmine: 0. And I wish I could rate her higher, I very, very much wish I could... and if there wasn't the preparatory apocalypsey dark mojo stuff she went through as Jasmordelia with The Beast's help, I would. If her dark side were just for eating people and killing those who broke her spell, she'd still rate around +2 or so for me. Universal peace and happiness = very good thing; screw free will.
 
Back
Top Bottom