Happy Birthday ©

GwenRaiden

AKA Apology Girl
Joined
Aug 26, 2008
Messages
6,939
Age
39
Location
Ecosse
Black Thorn
"Happy Birthday" is now in the public domain.

Thoughtlessly depriving Aaron Sorkin and numerous podcasters of precious material about the rapacious greed of songwriters Mildred and Patty Hill, a federal judge has ruled that Warner Chappell Music’s copyright on “Happy Birthday” is no longer valid, and that the popular ritual chant is now free for TV stars and teeth-gritted T.G.I.Friday’s employees alike.

Given the legally byzantine hoops that have long-surrounded the 25-note ditty, it seems fitting that Judge George King’s ruling stems not from what might seem like common sense—i.e., that the song is nearly a century old and that everyone involved in writing it is long past caring about either births or days—but from a copyright failure relating to the song’s initial publication. “Because Summy Co. never acquired the rights to the ‘Happy Birthday’ lyrics,” King declared, with no regard for how many semi-interesting birthday party conversations he was silencing, “Defendants, as Summy Co.’s purported successors-in-interest, do not own a valid copyright in the ‘Happy Birthday’ lyrics.” And just like that, “Happy Birthday” was freed, depriving Warner of the literal millions of dollars it earned from licensing the song every year.
Links: A.V. Club, The Hollywood Reporter, The Guardian
 
Between copyrights and patents (of which I hold one), I don't know what has done more damage to music and innovation. They both seem to be poker chips for major companies and no real innovation happens under their control. There was a woman who was taken to court and fleeced for $2000 for downloading "Happy Birthday" for her child's birthday party. Maybe she can go back to court and get her money back plus legal fees.
 
It's just insane. Like, how many people have sang "Happy Birthday" around the globe at a birthday celebration? How could they ever have enforced or controlled that anyway? Ridiculous.

Maybe she can go back to court and get her money back plus legal fees.

I hope she can and does!
 
It's just insane. Like, how many people have sang "Happy Birthday" around the globe at a birthday celebration? How could they ever have enforced or controlled that anyway? Ridiculous.
They couldn't.. that's why it was dismissed. But still the company thought they could have... which is why the paid (i think it was) a quarter of a billion dollars for the rights to the song... which is now public domain.
 
So will everyone who was wrongly fined get their money back as it seemingly always was public domain?
 
So will everyone who was wrongly fined get their money back as it seemingly always was public domain?
I never knew it was copyrighted until I read this, always thought it was public domain (Clearly, I have a lot to learn...)
 
Back
Top Bottom