Well I always thought 'Flooded' was the first episode I ever saw. I was over at a friend's house and her sister had taped this episode the previous night (it was the new episode, and those always aired like at 10 in Germany, and we were all rather young so she taped it) well and when I was over we were watching it. I liked it, but couldn't really watch a lot of episodes at home because of my parents. But I also remember this was around the time they played 'Walk through the Fire' a lot on Viva (a second MTV we have here).
Well, so I thought. Recently I read some old posts of me on a forum, and like 4 years back I wrote somewhere on this forum the first time I saw Buffy was when I was 9, which would be around 1999/2000, so probably s3. The problem is I can't recall this at all. Am I just repressing or what is the matter with me? lol