This is where I've been posting what issues we're reading each week:
https://buffy-boards.com/showthread.php?t=60713
We'll probably start ATF next week (doing the end of Season 9 and the first two issues of ATF).
We've been tweeting about them and then posting about them in the threads for each issue, rather than having a seperate "rewatch" thread. Though we could have one of those if we wanted.
It was my plan to do the entire Angel series, starting with After the Fall through issue #44. Then we will move on to get caught up with Angel & Faith. Maybe after that we will go back and do the one-shots and side series, unless someone has a better way to do it. We wanted to get through Angel & Faith as quickly as possible though, so we would all be up to date.