I Only Have Eyes for You, Underrated?

I think it's quite a strong episode, it's underpraised by fans of the show, where Buffy says that ''he doesn't deserve it'' only for the ''murderer'' to identify with her, is purely haunting as is the dialogue between her and Angelus. It's heartbreaking the scenes where Giles thinks its Ms. Calendar. The song is great, too. I do agree with you when you say that there isn't enough love for it on here.

I also find Killed By Death sort of underrated for similar reasons: great metaphors, unique monster and the creepy vibe Angelus gives the episode.
 
SRMarx
SRMarx
[No message]
I didn't think this episode was underrated... Almost everyone I've ever heard talk about the ep was generally in awe of the greatness of the acting and storytelling in IOHEFY.
 
I think so. I know for me personally, it's one of my all time favorite episodes. It fits the Angelus arc so perfectly, and the final scene where Buffy and Angelus are possessed, but the roles are reversed, it an incredibly powerful moment. The mystery of the episode is good and the actor who plays the kid from the 50's is now a main character on Covert Affairs, a show I really like.

"IOHEFY" is one of the best of S2 in my books.
 
I really like this episode. I find it both chilling and emotional. I love how they made Buffy and Angelus play the opposite roles that you think they would be playing, it was awesome. Definately one of my favourites in season 2 - I never seem to re-watch it often though - maybe it should just be enjoyed every now and then.
 
Wesley Pryce
Wesley Pryce
[No message]
This, quite honestly, is one of the best episodes in the entire series. The writing is so strong (Like all of them are, but this one comes in with just a little bit more strength) and there's that subtle touch of irony that exists between the spirit's relationship and Buffy/Angel.
 
SRMarx
SRMarx
[No message]
It is in my top 10 best episodes. And in my top 5 from S2. I love it. And I've never heard about anyone not liking it.
 
I don't think that it's underrated, it's just overshadowed by other episodes in season 2. When I think of season 2, I think of Becoming, Passion, Surprise, Innocence, and School Hard, since they're much more obviously part of the main storyline. This doesn't become part of the storyline until the end of the episode, so most people probably think of the Monster of the Week aspect before they think of the fact that it's part of the storyline. To me, it's a lot like Lie To Me in that I don't always watch it when I'm rewatching season 2, but it has stuff in it that is important to the overall story.
 
I wouldnt say this is an underrated episode, almost everyone I know love's this episode and I think its the episode that made Joss decide to give David his own show if I'm remembering correctly.

I however cannot stand this episode and laugh at both David and Sarah's acting in this episode because I find it so cringeworthy.
 
I didn't know this episode was 'underated' but I love it and think it's one of the most effective none story arc episodes from the entire series... bloody brilliant!
 
This is one of my fav episodes of the season if not the entire series. I wouldn't consider it underrated. I know everyone has so much love & appreciation for this episode & if they don't, they're crazy.
 
xfivebyfive said:
I however cannot stand this episode and laugh at both David and Sarah's acting in this episode because I find it so cringeworthy.
Click to expand...
I think Sarah's acting was really good, actually. I understand what you mean about David though. I don't think displaying sad emotion is his strong suit. He's much better at playing evil.
 
The first time I saw it years ago I was startled by the episode's intensity and gravity of themes. Let's face it: they tackled some pretty heavy material, as illicit teacher-student relations, murder-suicide, possession, wasp-swarms (!), visions of decomposing undead cadavers, Giles still grieving over Jenny, Buffy's Angel drama. Very heavy. :skull2:
Yeah, Davie's thespic talent was being stretched to the breaking-point, but, from what I remember, everyone else was spot on. It was definitely a stand-out episode, though perhaps not in the show's Top Ten.
 
VisionGirl
VisionGirl
[No message]
How can anyone forget this episode?
I found the scene where the ghost loop used Angel and Buffy brilliant. The words of the young boy coming from Buffy were so perfect it was difficult to remember that it wasn't actually her words yet In a way, they were.

That final moment when they kiss freeing the ghosts, Buffy looks at him and whispers "Angel?" with that spark of hope in her eyes. You almost want to believe it. That was powerful.

How can anyone not get anything from that?
 
Blaze
Blaze
[No message]
R
Robb Stark
[No message]
NeonNightLight
NeonNightLight
[No message]
SoulOfAngelus said:
How can anyone forget this episode?

How can anyone not get anything from that?
Click to expand...
Yup. I absolutely love this episode, and actually don't think that DB was rubbish in it. I think he proved time and again that he can act. Not in the same league as James Marsters, maybe, but Marsters is the real deal. Shakespeare and all that. For me, Boreanaz can carry and develop a character - show different aspects of the same character. He can do humour and tragedy, softness and passion. I honestly don't think there was a weak character or actor in the whole seven seasons!!

But then, I'm hopelessly hooked.....:smile3:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom