Joss Whedon Shuts Down Fan Campaign To Reboot ‘Firefly’

Abbeycat

Werewolf
Joined
Dec 5, 2010
Messages
2,558
Location
Mystic Falls
Sineya
The fan movement to help Nathan Fillion buy the rights of "˜Firefly' has been shut down after Joss Whedon and company publicly denounced the effort on Twitter.

A few weeks ago, Nathan Fillion mentioned that he'd buy the rights to the late, great, Firefly and start filming new episodes if he won the lottery. Subsequently, a few (hundred thousand) intrepid fans did their best to make that a reality, but www.helpnathanbuyfirefly.com has shut down after series creator Joss Whedon's sister-in-law publicly denounced the site on Twitter.

Maurissa Tancharoen is also a writer for such Whedon projects as Dollhouse and Doctor Horrible's Sing-Along Blog. This week she became a footnote in the colorful history of Firefly as well: after buzz about the fan movement reached a fever pitch, she sent out this Twitter message: Guys, no one in the Whedonverse is in support of www.helpnathanbuyfirefly.com. Please save your money!

Tancharoen later amended her statement with a longer message, stating that there were no hard feelings from the Whedon clan, but Joss and Co. weren't comfortable with fans trying to take direct control of the Firefly rights, and even less with them collecting real money to do so. After the news broke, the organizers put a short message on Facebook announcing an official end to their efforts.

It should be noted that the site never took any collections, merely pledges. While they fell short of anything like the $300 million that Fillion first joked about, the pledges were still impressive. Roughly 12,000 fans pledged just over a million US dollars, with an average pledge of $85. "˜Help Nathan Buy Firefly's Facebook page has 113,000 fans.

While I'd love to see Firefly on the air again as much as the next Browncoat, the movement had about a snowball's chance in a Capissen 38 engine. Fox was never under any obligation to sell the rights to Firefly "“ legitimately or not "“ and on the off chance that they saw millions of dollars worth of fan interest, they'd be much more likely to try a ham-fisted reboot themselves. Then there's commitments from the actors: Nathan Fillion, Morena Baccarin, Adam Baldwin and Summer Glau (nevermind) all have steady gigs on other shows, to say nothing of Whedon himself, who's knee-deep in superheroes right now writing and directing The Avengers. Let's face it: it's coming up on ten years since the series was cancelled, and Serenity was a fitting, if bittersweet, end to the franchise.

It was fun while it lasted, folks. The "˜Help Nathan Buy Firefly' organizers accomplished a lot in a short time, bringing a bunch of people some fanservice on Facebook and generating buzz for worthy projects like Child's Play, Whedon's equality charity Can't Stop the Serenity and fan movie Browncoats: Redemption. If nothing else, this incident showed how deeply "˜the little TV show that couldn't' has embedded itself in the hearts and minds of geeks everywhere.

Don't forget, Science Channel is currently rebroadcasting all fourteen episodes of Firefly Sunday nights at 10 PM "“ and Captain Mal himself seems to be dropping Firefly and Serenity references every other week on Castle.

SOURCE
 
I became a fan of it on facebook when it first started because I thought people were taking it as the "haha wouldn't it be cool if..." thing it was supposed to be. I was kind of shocked they didn't actually take it this way...
 
Glad the Whedons finally cleared things up! I had a feeling the hardcore fans wouldn't give up until Joss himself put his opinion out there. Still, I'm pretty impressed by how much money (in pledges) they did raise...over a million dollars? Dang.
 
You gotta wonder though... What percentage of that pledge would people REALLY be willing to give up. I mean I'm an overly enthusiastic person. If I legit thought this could have happened, I might have pledged like $100. But I wouldn't be able to afford more than MAYBE $20. But when pledging it's like "you don't actually have to give any... just how much would you like to give" and I'd be like "OOH I'd give $100 or more!" I suspect with an average pledge of $85, that's likely what happened in a lot of cases.
 
I'm glad someone stepped up and put an end to this before actual money was involved. The whole endeavour has made me feel uncomfortable from the very beginning.

It still leaves me with a bit of a sour feeling though, because I kind of feel that it should have been Nathan Fillion himself to take a stance, since he was the one who set the whole thing off. I know he said something along the lines of "I can't believe people took that seriously" in various podcasts, but as people very obviously did, I feel that it should have been his responsibility to set the record straight a bit more publicly. Seriously, what would it have cost him to say something on Twitter, or even compose a press statement?

I don't know, but NF has lost a bit of credit with me for that.
 
Last edited:
F
FetalPig
you give credit? i'll be right over ... ;)
Yeah but if you think about it, fans run with this kind of thing all the time. Maybe not to quite this extent...but I can guarantee you that every. single. time. Joss & Co go to a con, they get asked about rebooting the series. It would seem like a waste of time for them to address every last proposition. Nathan said he would try to buy the rights if he won the lottery. He has 0% responsibility for what the fans did with that statement so he shouldnt need to address it.
 
Yeah but if you think about it, fans run with this kind of thing all the time. Maybe not to quite this extent...but I can guarantee you that every. single. time. Joss & Co go to a con, they get asked about rebooting the series. It would seem like a waste of time for them to address every last proposition. Nathan said he would try to buy the rights if he won the lottery. He has 0% responsibility for what the fans did with that statement so he shouldnt need to address it.

I've had this discussion before... my flatmate is of the exact same opinion as you. You're right of course about fans doing this kind of thing all the time, but to my knowledge no initiative has taken it this far before. As I said, I know he wasn't being serious, but I still think that as a public persona that people look up to, NF carries a certain responsibility towards these people.
 
I've had this discussion before... my flatmate is of the exact same opinion as you. You're right of course about fans doing this kind of thing all the time, but to my knowledge no initiative has taken it this far before. As I said, I know he wasn't being serious, but I still think that as a public persona that people look up to, NF carries a certain responsibility towards these people.

Really? How about the initiative that got Universal, one of the biggest studios around, to pick up a movie based on a TV show that had been cancelled after half a season, 3 years beforehand? You know, Serenity.

Believe me, as far as Browncoats go, this movement was pretty mild. We're talking about pledges here - not money. It doesn't compare to when Browncoats gave actual money to have Serenity put on U.S. Navy ships for the crews to watch. The only difference is that, as opposed to the previous Browncoats movements, this one was based on a terrible idea. Bringing Firefly back is not a bad idea - but having fans buy the rights to a TV show? No thanks. Seriously, even if there was enough money, which there clearly isn't, because production is about much more that buying rights, I personally don't want a Firefly that's owned by Browncoats. Why? Cause they're crazy! (and yeah, I'm including myself). Imagine Firefly's rights were bought with fan money. What happens the next time Joss decides to kill a character? What if the writers take artistic liberties that the fans don't like? They withdraw their money, stop funding the show, everything goes south. Honestly, I don't want to think about the writers of Firefly having to flinch every time a blogger says something bad about the show. Sorry, but this was a bad idea to begin with.
 
P
prophecygrrl
Well, some people got scammed out of real money, not just pledges
Back
Top Bottom