Kiss, Marry, Kill Part Deux

[Anya2012]

Kiss Clem
Kill the Toth
Marry the Gentlemen

Jenny, Olivia, Anya

 

[Aimee]

Kiss Jenny
Marry Anya
Kill Olivia

Jonathon, Andrew, Warren

 

[NightBird]

If I really have to..

Kill:Warren
Kiss:Andrew
Marry:Jonathon


Ben, Glory, Dreg (Glory minion)

 

[Aimee]

Kiss Ben
Marry Glory
Kill Dreg

Buffy, Faith, Kendra

 

[Cheese Slices]

Marry Buffy
Kiss Kendra
Kill Faith (sorry about that)

William, Liam, human!Dru

 

[caitaintdead]

Kiss - Liam
Marry - William
Kill - Human Dru

School Girl Darla, Human Darla, Freshly turned Darla

 

[bottark]

Kiss - School Girl Darla
Marry - Human Darla
Kill - Freshly turned Darla

Puppet Sid (1x09 "Puppet Show"), Polo (Smile Time main puppet), one of Sweet's henchmen?

 

[Anya2012]

Kiss Sid the Puppet
Kill Polo
Marry one of Sweet's henchmen

Sweet, Lorne, The Beast?

 

[Aimee]

Kiss Sweet
Marry Lorne
Kill the beast

The Mayor, Glory and Adam

 

[Anya2012]

Kill Adam
Kiss the Mayor
Marry Glory

Clem, Jinx (Glory's minion), Ben

 

[Aimee]

What a choice!

Kill Jinx
Kiss Clem
Marry Ben

Owen, (vampire) Harmony, Johnathon

 

[Anya2012]

Kill Owen
Kiss Harmony
Marry Jonathan

Darla, Drusilla, Angelus?

 

[randiann]

Kiss Darla
Marry Angelus (plus curse)
Kill Drusilla

Mr. Pointy, Mr. Gordo, and Miss Kitty Fantastico?

 

[mamarsh18]

Kiss: Miss Kitty Fantastico
Marry: Mr. Pointy.. (Can you marry an inanimate object?)
Kill: Mr. Gordo

Vampire Willow, Evil Witch Willow, Regular normal Willow?

 

[Cheese Slices]

Kiss Vampire Willow
Marry Regular Willow
Kill Evil Willow

Caleb, Glory, Mr Trick

 

[Aimee]

Kiss Mr Trick
Marry Glory
Kill Caleb

S2 evil Spike, S5 Spike with a chip, S7 Spike with a soul

 

[randiann]

Can I kiss S2 Spike and kill the other two?

I'll say kiss s2 Spike (whom I love)
Kill S5 Spike (whom I loathe)
and Marry S7 Spike....but then I'm gonna stake him.

Robin Wood, Kennedy, and Uber Vamp?

 

[Anya2012]

Marry Robin Wood
Kiss ubervamp
Kill Kennedy (Yay, I killed Kennedy!)

Vi, Rona, Chloe?

 

[Cheese Slices]

Kiss Chloe
Marry Vi
Kill Rona

Wes s3 Btvs, Giles s1, Wes s5 ats

 

[Aimee]

Kiss Giles S1
Kill Wes S3 BTVS
Marry Wes S5 AtS (best 'marry' option EVER) 😉

Ethan, Joyce & Giles