Kiss, Marry, Kill

[SpikesGrrl4Real]

Kiss Fred, Marry Twilight, Kill Satsu

Giles, Ethan, First Slayer

 

[Anya2012]

Marry Giles
Kiss Ethan Rayne
Kill the First Slayer

Kathy, Parker, Adam

 

[Leeson]

Kiss Kathy
Marry Adam
Kill Parker

Dark!Willow, Jasmine!Cordelia, Twangel

 

[riceballalien]

Kiss Jasmine/Cordelia
Marry Dark Willow
Kill Twangel

The Master, D'Hoffryn, Veruca

 

[Anya2012]

Marry D'Hoffryn
Kiss the Master
Kill Veruca

Sunday, Percy, Olaf the troll

 

[brinkster130]

Marry: Percy
Kiss: Sunday
Kill: Olaf


Doyle (in demon form), Anya (in demon form), Angel (in demon form)

 

[VisionGirl]

Doyle (in demon form)-marry
Anya (in demon form)-kill
Angel (in demon form)- kiss! Although I know that I should probably kill him, but I can't. Hey, I'm just like Buffy!

The trio:
Warren, Andrew, Jonathan

 

[Jay Jade]

Kiss Jonathan
Marry Andrew
Kill Warren

Xander, Spike, Tara

 

[Rack]

What's a bloke to do?

Kiss Spike
Marry Tara
Kill Xander

Halfreck, Drucilla, Amy

 

[Leeson]

Kiss Halfreck
Marry Drusilla
Kill Amy

Kennedy, Caleb, Dawn

 

[BananaBuffy]

Kiss Kennedy (well...I mean...she's hot.)
Marry Dawn
Kill Caleb

Natalie French (the old one, not the bug pretending to be her), The zookeeper from The Pack, Amy's mother.

 

[SlayerFest]

Kiss the zookeeper
Marry Natalie French
Kill Amy's mom

Willow, Fred, Fred's mom

 

[Leeson]

Kiss Fred's Mom
Marry Fred
Kill Willow

Might make for an awkward Christmas, but I just can't kill Trish.

Groosalugg, Anne Steele, Lee Mercer

 

[strawberryeve]

kiss anne steele
marry groosalug
kill lee mercer

Fred, Illyria, Faith

 

[Anya2012]

Marry Faith
Kiss Fred
Kill Illyria (payback for killing Fred)

Glory, Ben, crazy Tara

 

[Leeson]

Kiss Ben
Marry Crazy!Tara
Kill Glory

Lindsey, Lilah, Eve

 

[brinkster130]

Kiss: Lilah
Marry: Lindsay
Kill: Eve


Jonathan, Andrew, Warren

 

[Anya2012]

Marry Andrew
Kiss Jonathan
Kill Warren

Clem, Buffy-Bot, Harmony

 

[EvilWillow]

Kiss Clem
Marry Harmony
Kill Buffy-bot


Anya, Fred, Buffy

 

[Anya2012]

Marry Anya
Kiss Buffy
Kill Fred

Graham, Forest, Quentin Travers