Rank the Season 4 Episodes

[Mr Trick]

@Fuffy Baith I can see how Beer Bad is maybe more entertaining than Doomed 😀 To be fair for all the stick it gets at times S4 is very consistent episode to episode. Very few bad ones.

 

[Fuffy Baith]

@Fuffy Baith I can see how Beer Bad is maybe more entertaining than Doomed 😀 To be fair for all the stick it gets at times S4 is very consistent episode to episode. Very few bad ones.

I find Beer Bad to be funny, and Cave Buffy is adorable. I know season 4 gets some hate, but I really enjoy season 4, the quality is mostly consistent, but it's low quality. Most episodes are good but not great and there's some poor episodes.

 

[Mr Trick]

I find Beer Bad to be funny, and Cave Buffy is adorable. I know season 4 gets some hate, but I really enjoy season 4, the quality is mostly consistent, but it's low quality. Most episodes are good but not great and there's some poor episodes.

Yeah, but on avenge I'd give a S4 episode 7/10. That's not a bad avenge. Then you have at least three of the best episodes of the whole show (Hush, Restless, This Year's Girl/Who Are You). There's only really a couple that are terrible IMO. Even something like Doomed has its moments. Its medicore rather than bad I think.

 

[Ireflection]

Restless
Who Are You
Hush
This Year's Girl
Fear, Itself
Something Blue
A New Man
Superstar
Living Conditions
The Freshman
The Yoko Factor
Wild at Heart
Primeval
The Harsh Light of Day
New Moon Rising
The Initiative
Pangs
The I in Team
Goodbye Iowa
Beer Bad
Doomed
Where the Wild Things Are

 

[Doppelgangers]

I actually love this season, many great episode. It's not a coincidence though that all the Initiative heavy eps are at the bottom of my list.

22.Beer Bad
21.Doomed
20.The Initiative
19.Goodbye Iowa
18.The I in Team
17.The Freshman
16.Living Conditions
15.Where the Wild Thing Are
14.The Harsh Light of Day
13.Pangs
12.A New Man
11.The Yoko Factor
10.Primeval
9.Superstar
8.Wild at Heart
7.Fear, Itself
6.Something Blue
5.Who Are You
4.This Year's Girl
3.New Moon Rising
2.Hush
1.Restless

I would have roughly this same order, with a note that when I first saw Superstar I thought it was trash, but came to like it a lot. Faith and Oz are only around for a while but both play big parts in some great episodes.

 

[TamsinValencia]

1.Who Are You?
2.New Year's Girl
3. Hush
4. Beer Bad
5. Restless
6. The Freshman
7.Living Conditions
8.Wild at Heart
9.New Moon Rising
10. Something Blue
11.The Harsh Light of Day
12. Primeval
13. The initiative
14. The I in team
15. Where the Wild Things Are
16. A New Man
17. The Yoko Factor
18. Pangs
19. Goodbye Iowa
20. Superstar
22. Doomed

 

[BaskingINBangel]

1. Restless
2. Hush
3. Pangs
4. Who Are You?
5. Fear Itself
6. Something Blue
7. Living Conditions
8. This Year's Girl
9. A New Man
10. Primeval
11. The Freshman
12. Where The Wild Things Are
13. Beer Bad
14. The Yoko Factor
15. Wild At Heart
16. The Harsh Light of Day
17. Superstar
18. New Moon Rising
19. Doomed
20. The Initiative
21. Goodbye Iowa
22. The I In Team