I'm in love with the nostalgia provided by Roswell more than I am in love with the show itself. Like, I just recently re-watched the show (I skipped a lot of episodes in S2. I could not with that blue jellyfish thing) and I could see who were the stronger actors and the weaker ones. Unfortunately, who was strong and weak didn't match up with my faves.
It had a really strong first season and if they kept with that kind of writing and direction, it would've been amazing for three whole seasons. Unfortunately, S2 & 3 got way silly and started suffering from a lot of behind the set stuff and Katims decision to stop being about relationships that have other worldly exceptions and just went with "ALIENS. EFF YEAH" and didn't even do THAT well.