William Shatner was famous all his life for one role as Captain Kirk in the last 78 of the 79 episodes of the show and really couldn't shake his association with it until Boston Legal, dacades later.
I do think SMG came across as ungrateful to the BtVS fans for her success. When an actress almost refuses to be involved in anything to promote the show, such as con panels, interviews, and commentaries for DVDs, it kind of looks like they don't want to be associated with the show, to me.
The fact that Sarah so rarely did anything that was specifically for BtVS back in the day pretty much proves that she didn't want to be associated with the show, which is insulting to me. We, as fans, are the people who helped make her famous... She should be a lot more grateful to the fans and to the show.
I get that she wanted to do new things and experience other types of roles, but Sarah was getting movie roles and things. Why should be be annoyed to keep doing BtVS if it was still good writing and still making her money?
It's her job, it's not her fandom. How do you expect to be taken seriously as an actress when your major credit is "Buffy the Vampire Slayer"? And just because she was ready to move on after season 3, doesn't make her ungrateful. EVERYONE wants to move up in their career, and no one wants to have to do the same exact thing for 7 years.
I always got the impression that she had a great enthusiasm about the show and its fans.
I'm probably being a brash gobshite, but you know what, whatever. I have one question.
WHO CARES?!
Did it affect the quality of the show, like more than the writers' garbage? No way. Does it affect the enjoyment I derive from watching Ms Gellar's performance? No, not at all.
It's like if you were asked to constantly be doing extra work outside of your usual workday. When I was working on set the only thing I wanted to do on my day off was sleep, and I didn't have to be "on" performing the whole time and go home and learn my lines for the next day. I don't blame her one bit for not wanting to fill up her little free time, especially when she was a newlywed, doing cons and press junkets.
Also, she does seem to have a habit of turning down roles so she doesn't have to be away from her family. She did this with Stardust. Not saying there's anything wrong with that, but she's limiting herself due to that. It doesn't seem as though she's doing her utmost to be known for something other than Buffy.
At some point, the money isn't worth it anymore. Having no life, and then when you finally have time, having to fit in the movies that you actually want to do?
The fact that Sarah stayed throughout the entire run of the show to me shows that she was respectful of the show and the fans.
I'm not hating on SMG, but that stuff is part and parcel of movie/tv stardom. So it is no excuse to me.
What roll in Stardust did she turn down? The beautiful girl who sends the boy off on the adventure?
She was offered Clare Danes role in Stardust (and supposedly Romeo and Juliet)
Yeah cause Clare Danes is so huge now lol