Sarahs acting abilities?

Yeah, I can't say much good about Charmed, but I was thinking today that Piper isn't half bad. Cole too, but everyone's always so "BEAT YOU IN THE HEAD YOU'RE BAD" all the time I can't even see the guy I love in all the other shows he's in.

Perhaps this is why I don't like Charmed and DO like Spike. I ADORE gray areas!
 
Sarah is a great actress.
I can say that without a doubt because there is nothing i hate more than bad actors in a big role.
Sarah is completely believable when she speaks her lines. It always bothered me when people say she cant act.
 
i think she's fantastic and has just had bad luck in what she's chose film wise.... please send her luck everyone who likes her come on *mind power*
 
BtVS wouldn't be at the level that it is if the main actress stunk.

I love Sarah Michelle Geller, I think she's a really good actress. She is totally and completely believable as Buffy. Even during fight scenes when it's so obvious the stunt double isn't SMG, you still believe in Buffy, you still believe in Sarah. Yes, that has a lot to do with the writers, directors, etc, but BtVS wouldn't be what it is (timeless) if SMG sucked.
 
I agree.
She doesn't suck.
And she IS GREAT in Buffy. She IS Buffy and as much as I've always rolled my eyes at the sight of her name in credits....I have to admit that once I saw Buffy I said, "AH HA! Perhaps this is IT!"
She's definately Buffy. Other people...I don't know. I've really never seen her in anything else that I saw the character and not either SMG or Buffy.

But, she gets VERY high points for Buffy.

I actually do have faith that she's better than she comes across. I don't think she's taking the roles that would or could steer her away from Buffyness and into other things. She needs to steer clear of both horror and movies where she's gotta Kung-Fu people.
If she's gotta do horror...I think she should be the scary killer person.

I do think that with all the actors out there, she's on the losing side of the teeter totter, but I'm not sure that she HAS to be. I think she just needs to work less on trying to get us to seperate her from Buffy and more on doing less "Buffy type" rolls.
Like, CSI investigator!
 
I was thinking about this last night, I think she is awesome as Buffy. But I do think she also needs to choose her current roles more carefully. I haven't seen her in anything lately that has shown off her acting abilities at all. (Although I am fresh from watching Southland tales and I am still confused as to if the character was written badly or the acting was bad... maybe the whole movie was just bad...)
 
this is what she needs - http://www.mutantreviewers.com/rjg11.html

Have a space on your mantle that needs sprucing up? Want to be the envy of all your pets? Need something you can hollow out and use as a pepper shaker? Well then, why don't you just win an Oscar? It's easy and fun! We'll show you how to do it the MRFH way!

Step 1

You have to star in an "Oscar vehicle", which is to say, a drama, suspense or adventure piece. If you're in a comedy, kid flick, horror, sci-fi, animated, or even a relatively ground-breaking piece of cinema, you're just shooting yourself in the foot. See: The English Patient, Schindler's List

Step 2

Some good Oscar vehicles are biopics (stories of a real person's life), courtroom films, or musicals. A true life story about Julie Andrews' court battle over song copyright infringement, for instance, would be ideal. See: Erin Brockovich, Chicago

Step 3

To hedge your bets even further, star in a movie that's either a period piece with lots of fancy costumes and elaborate sets, or a gritty ghetto morality tale about the dangers of drugs. A heroin addict in 17th century France would be just ducky. You could also be in a movie that makes some sort of clumsy gesture of reconciliation toward an oppressed people/race/minority group. See: Chocolat, Braveheart, Traffic

Step 4

Jack up your chances by playing a mentally or physically handicapped person. People will fawn all over you for this, even though you - a perfectly healthy actor - got the role over someone with this actual disorder. The Academy Award is repeatedly astounded by an actor's ability to walk strange, talk funny, or babble incoherently for long stretches of time. See: Rain Man, A Beautiful Mind, Forrest Gump

Step 5

Another sure-fire way to win is to die by the end of the movie. A martyr's death is grand, but if that can't be arranged, have your character either be unjustly murdered on the eve of his greatest happiness, or whither away from a terminal illness. Terminal illness characters have the best screen time to give long meandering speeches about life that will make the audience sob like school children, so this is a pretty good way to go. See: Gladiator, Philadelphia, Ed Wood, Leaving Las Vegas, Dead Man Walking, Titanic...

Step 6

Have some memorable catchphrase or speech associated with the film so that the common public can remember which movie it is. See: "Show me the money!", "Life is like a box of chocolates"

Step 7

The Academy loves either ultra-happy endings or "spiral down into a pit of shame and despair and hopelessness and cookie dough gluttony" endings that symbolize the doom of mankind. They simply cannot make up their minds which way is better. Preferably, a happy ending where someone good dies. See: Monster, The Pianist, Shakespeare in Love

Step 8

When you go to the Oscars, don't forget to be a complete jerk. Do something weird, like wearing a bizarre outfit, french kiss a relative in front of the camera, make some extreme political statement, and overinflate your ego to the point where it might legally challenge Godzilla for domination over Tokyo. See: Roberto Benigni, Michael Moore, Bjork

Step 9

Have some victory speech planned that consists of (1) you crying or looking constipated, (2) you thanking everyone you've ever met, even though the audience just DOES NOT CARE, (3) thank God, even if you're a satanic chicken worshipper, (4) start snapping at the band music when it swells up to get you off the stage, and (5) act like a magnanimous prick, as if you actually accomplished something bigger than curing cancer or bringing peace to the Middle East. See: Halle Berry barking like a dog during the 2001 Oscars
 
I adore SMG, I think she's a talented actress. She's great in all (or *most*) of her movies, especially the horror and drama ones (Cruel Intentions, The Grudge, The Air I Breathe). I think she's able to make the characters she plays "believable", in the sense that the viewers become engaged. She can play varied roles with different tones and approaches (some bad actors/actresses seem to be just one person in all of their movies). The one SMG movie that I dislike is The Return, I think both the film sucks and her acting is not at her best. I haven't seen Southland Tales yet (I heard pretty low reviews on it though).

She was excellent in Buffy, Joss couldn't have picked a better actress for that role. I think she's better suited in horror, mystery, drama, and action-type movies.
 
i never had any desire to see any of sarah michelle gellar's other work because they weren't my "thing," but i loved buffy from the first episode i saw and i think smg is brilliant as buffy. she acts her well and believably, and i mentioned in another post the other day, that after a while the actors kind of "become" the characters in some form when they play one person for many years.
 
I do have to admit, that I think some of SMG BEST acting was as the Buffybot.
She was simply brillant then!
 
P
punkypower
agreed. that, and as faith, of course! **wink, wink**
I think SMG acting is supperb, but in The Grudge 1 and 2 it wasn't brilliant. Then again the film wasn't that great either.
 
I'm biased.

I've been a SMG fan since "Swan's Crossing" and "All My Children." She can play any emotion/characteristic almost flawlessly, rather it be the rich bisque (Swans Crossing/Cruel Intentions), i will survive chick (btvs), scream queen (ikwydls, scream2) or bitter, confused sloppy seconds daughter (amc). Honestly, I haven't watched anything of hers post-BtVS except Scooby Doo and The Grudge, which were forgettable for me.

I can't see anyone else playing Buffy. She gave us all of the blood, sweat and tears that Joss put into the script. She could go to that deep, dark place in season 6, and then in the next scene, have us cracking up with the BuffyBot.

I truly hope Sarah has a great comeback soon (I guess something Buffy-related would be TOO much, huh? :àž)
 
V
Violette
Very well said :) I've never seen her in "Swan's Crossing", but I do believe that SMG is a great talented actress and she always seemed to make her roles believable, including her movies.
I'll have to say that I loved SMG in Buffy and think she acted well, however saying that I think she has been terrible in every other film i've seen her in.
 
I agree with some of you guys, everytime I see SMG in a movie all I think is "Buffy, Buffy, Buffy, she's Buffy"..SMG is great as Buffy, I couldn't imagine anyone else in the role, but I think she is more suited to TV acting rather than movie acting though, I think as an actress she has peaked.
 
i love sarah, always liked her as buffy i think her best acting performance would be as katherine in cruel intentions perhaps it was a lil different than anything else and the first time i didnt think of her as buffy, other than that shes not the best but an ok actress, i dont think she can do horror though she doesnt play fear very well i really didnt like her in the grudge it was awfull
 
It's funny how most people say if you really wanna see what Sarah is capable of as an actress in Buffy, to watch The Body...while she was undeniably good there...I was most moved by her performance in The Gift, in particular her scene with Giles. When she says "I don't know how to live in this world if these are the choices" I found that to just be spine-tingling...maybe it's just me. Her acting came across as pretty forced and lame in some of the season 1 episodes...but all the actors seemed to struggle a bit in the first season.
 
Back
Top Bottom