Chet said:
There's another huge strike against Tru Calling picking up new audience -- it's highly episodic, and despite appearances a subtle and complicated premise.
Imagine someone watching the Season Two opener as their introduction to the show. Their heads would explode. They'll have to recap and explain the show premise and the whole first season -- and that wouldn't be a fun episode to watch, "too complicated." Word to the wise: issue season one on DVD before season two premieres.
Fox would be wise to emphasize the crime-story nature of the show in some promos -- after all, crime drama is still hot. How does a Buffy-Meets-CSI show not find an audience? CSI types never hear of it, that's how.
The best we can hope is that the show is relatively cheap (as dramas go) and slowly builds a cult-like audience among the Revlon/Tampax set so Fox can sell the ad time and make money.
!Chet
P.S. I hope "Joey" does as well as "Time of your life."
I generally agree. There is a lot of subtle background info that newcomers will miss out on, although as long as people understand that someone dies, they ask Tru for help, the day rewinds, and she tries to save them, they'll probably pick up pretty quickly on Jack's deal, even if all the intricacies aren't known. The opener for Season Two may have to "stand on its own" a bit if they have it in mind to attract new viewers that way. There are ways to do reintroduction while keeping it subtle (call everyone by name early on, also refer to what they are "Harrison, you're my little brother, I can't let you..." or "Davis, just because you're my boss doesn't mean...", bring up something old when something new is mentioned "Again? Well...he's not the first criminal you've had to save."). If it were up to me, I'd almost do the Season Two opener as a two hour movie on a Sunday night, just to rope in more viewers and potential fans.
I'd like to see Season One on DVD before then also, but it's hard to say if it'd happen. I think with proper promotion, Fox could sell a whole ton of Tru Calling DVDs to people who never got around to watching the show or wanted to watch something else instead on Thursday nights. I'd also really like to see some reruns over the summer/early fall, even if it's Friday at midnight or weekdays at 1pm or something weird like that. It costs them nothing to rerun, but it gives another chance for people to pick up the show and see how good it is.
I also agree about the CSI connection. I've heard Tru Calling mentioned as sort of a "procedural crime show" many times, and I don't know why they don't play that up more. Most things seem to focus on the supernatural aspect of the show, which will not draw a mainstream audience. What will is the CSI style, working backwards to solve the crime aspect, the intense, race against the clock 24-style aspect, and even the relationship aspect where the characters are all closely working with or against each other with a lot at stake.
I think the show has the potential for a cult following. I think Fox thinks it is potentially the next Buffy and wants to give it a chance. They don't really have much (any?) other sci-fi right now, so it makes sense to keep the show, at least for a while. Eliza and Jason lend a bit of star power as well, so that's another reason to expect the audience may grow over time. I say it gets an order for 10-13 episodes to start mid-season. If it does well or gains "cult hit" status, it gets a complete second season, and probably a couple more after that. If not, it's cancelled after the filmed eps run. If they bump TC to Fridays, they basically guarantee it'll die - if the demographic is females 18-34, they're out having a good time on Friday nights, not in watching TV (for the most part).
edit: as a weird aside, I'm a programmer/geek, so to me, !Chet means not-Chet
🙂