BotD,
You're not "getting" it. It's not that your wrong, exactly, just not entirely correct and the option you're not seeing isn't black and white.
First of, just to refresh your memory, we're talking about kids who are currently 5 and 8 and were younger at the time. So, it's not like I was going to sit down and discuss with them the ins and outs of heterosexuals vs. homosexuals. I didn't try to HIDE anything, necessarily, I just tried to keep things as "G" rated as them seeing Mommy and Daddy together or Grandma and Grandpa together.
They could SEE our friends John and Phil were not the same as say their Uncle and his roommate. There was something there that they saw was different.
We could say, "They love each other" and in their heads they could rationalize that my brother loves his roommate too (in a different way), but they just KNEW something was "off". They asked if they were going to get married once. What do I say to that? "Um...no, let me explain how this country is convinced our friends are evil and don't deserve to file a joint tax return....." It's more about how a child's mind works. They grow up thinking their life is like everyone else's. You grow up, fall in love, get married and have babies. Well, those last two, our friends can't really do.
As a mother, even when they didn't say it, I could see that it bugged them. Not really the actual relationship, more that they couldn't "get it". My sister tried to explain it to HER 5 year old before she watched Buffy and stupidly threw in that the President and the Bible were against it. What is a 5 year old supposed to think? She wasn't trying to be biased, just give all the information. But, to a kid, you throw in the president and God and WHA-LA...it must be wrong. Until, SHE watched Buffy and then suddenly quit debating with my kids about how wrong it was.
We're open minded, sure, so you're right that they probably had some predisposition to being that way. But, you also should realize that at least in THIS country, all shows and toys are geared toward the heterosexual family. You don't turn on the Disney Channel and see families dealing with having "two Mommies". All their friends have a Mommy and a Daddy. All their shows have a Mommy and a Daddy. In a child's mind, "This is how the world works". It's no more weird than having someone say, "There is no Santa Claus" or "Not everyone owns a TV" in their heads. They can't conceive of the notion and it makes no sense.
You said
I do not for one second believe that Willow and Tara made anyone 'tolerant' of Gay and Lesbian, it may have made people understand it a bit more HOWEVER, if you were anti-gay before it, you still would be.
No, my kids weren't "anti-gay" exactly. But, you don't have to far over into the side of Anti-Gay to be more understanding and tolerant. The story and how well it was executed, with no 3 episodes of dwelling on the politics of it or how one friend "couldn't accept it", and it DID open their eyes to understanding. In fact, it put my daughter right smack into the camp of, love is just there and it doesn't matter who it is. And, there IS no saying that over time, they WOULDN'T have become anti-gay. I don't think any kid is born anti-gay, it comes from what they learn growing up. Willow and Tara helped them get it because of how it was executed.
You're the one who said "anyone". They count as anyone. Maybe not the ones you MEANT, but they do count.