Super Sarah

[white avenger]

If you were going to make a superhero movie starring Sarah Michelle Gellar, who would you cast her as? Only one stipulation: the character can have absolutely nothing to do with demons, vampires, Slayers, or the occult in any way.

My choice would be either Nightwing or Supergirl.


Yes, an existing superhero (unless you can come up with a really fantastic new idea)

 

[Mr. Pointy]

Off the top of my head - I can see her in a 'Hawk and Dove' film but I suspect I need to give this some more thought...good topic WA.

I'm guessing you're not thinking of the Dick Grayson version of Nightwing here, which is the character I know...please feel free to remind me about the lady Nightwing(s).

 

[Fake Shemp]

i think she would have made a FANTASTIC sue storm in Fantastic Four.

 

[Superstar]

The girl in red

Yes, an existing superhero (unless you can come up with a really fantastic new idea)

Well Jungle Girl gets my vote.
DYNAMITE-The Boys, Project Superpowers, Red Sonja, Army of Darkness, The Lone Ranger, Zorro & More!
With Eliza as Cavewoman to compliment the above choice...
http://www.basementcomics.com/

But... I'd say Scarlet Witch from Marvel Comics even though it breaks your "occult" rule.
Visual Aid:

Oh, and here's a kicker for ya:
Robert Rodriguez reteams with Rose McGowan in 'Red Sonja' - USATODAY.com

Rose McGowan as Red Sonja. Who woulda thunk it?

 

[Fake Shemp]

i like jessica sure, but sarah looks like sue..... even ali larter should have been sue over jessica

 

[Tranquillity]

After looking at that pic posted by Superstar, i think she could work as Black Canary

Black Canary - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Mr. Pointy]

I think she would work as Ice/Ice Maiden in a Justice League film, or possibly as Donna Troy in a Wonder Woman movie , or Saturn Girl in a Legion of Super Heroes film...failing those, isn't one of the Powerpuff Girls blonde 🙂? Going non-DC, how about The Wasp?

 

[Blondie Bear]

^ Okay, now I'm confused. Do you mean Diana Prince in a Wonder Woman movie, or Donna Troy in a Wonder Girl or Teen Titans movie?

I am a nerd. *slinks off*

 

[Mr. Pointy]

^ Okay, now I'm confused. Do you mean Diana Prince in a Wonder Woman movie, or Donna Troy in a Wonder Girl or Teen Titans movie?

I am a nerd. *slinks off*

Nope, I meant Donna Troy...Lucy Lawless would obviously 😉 be Wonder Woman (if Charisma Carpenter was unavailable) but there is no reason that Donna Troy couldn't appear in the same film...Sarah would not make a good Diana...I put it to you that you are not nerd enough 🙂

Actually, I could live with the Titans film...SMG would probably be better as Starfire in that though 🙂