Supernatural?

I'm suprised on how two shows with the same background as the supernatural and hunting them, yada yada, canfeel so different. (for what its worth, I like both shows.)

Sam and Dean are kind of like having two 'slayers'...it puts me to mind what could have been if Faith had just been rowdy instead of evil in season 3, and all the other scoobies died. Sam is clearly more 'slayer like' having the demon blood in him and having 'powers' derived from darkness, but Dean has been to hell and faced his own darkness plus he's involved with 'Angels' 😛

With Buffy I always got the feeling of family and home, trying to have super powers and responsibilities while growing up and having a somewhat normal life with friends and mentors and school....I just don't get that at all with the Winchester fellas, they seem more high plains drifter to me. It's fortunate they have each other (and at times Giles...errr..Bobby) so they don't feel totally isolated.

I actually see alot of similarities...dying for family, fighting a fight no one knows about, not all deamons being bad, the importance of family and friends. having to grow up quick and being exposed to walking nightmares incredibly young (dean more so than sam.) Big brother protecting little brother from his purpose like some certain Summers sisters. Worry over where certain unatural gifts come from, Romance between...well I won't spoil it...

To me the biggest difference is that Sam and Dean are hunted by the authorities, other hunters, and of course deamons too. They have no Sunnydale or Bronze or Xanders basement. They have a car, their mission and each other, thats it. (though they are developing a 'core four'.) There life does not seem nearly as happy. Maybe thats why it feels so different to me despite all the similarities. Buffy might have had some incredibly sad moments...but to me overall it feels more up-beat than Supernatural. Supernatural has honestly spooked me with its stories at times and that is something Buffy never did. It seems much darker to me. That is why I probably prefer Buffy more, but I really like both shows.
 
^ I'm not sure how I feel about the authorities thing, with the F.B.I. etc chasing them. Yes, it's realistic, but I think it makes their job exponentially harder than it maybe ought to be, and possibly adds too much to the plot. I don't HATE it, but I think the show could possibly do without it.
 
^^ I agree, but I wonder how they would pull that off?

That might make it easier for them to have a home...I mean they do have Bobby's panic room but really no chance at life non-transiant. If they had roots though, I'm not sure the show would feel the same, not that a change would necessarily be a bad thing, but I think the law being after them and the way possesion works on the show and how all those injuries come back to the victim after the demon is gone....there are alot more civilian casulties; I think that it makes sense the law is after them, unless you get government involvement or devine intervention.

They are always going to be breaking the law when the impersonate FBI officials to get into crime scenes and just fighting their fight...that whole giving names based of Rock stars and pop culture...I would miss that if they somehow got involved with the law or some "Iniative" like project, I don't think I'd like that at all.

I think I do see what your saying though, it kinda intrudes in on some of the supernaturalness of the plot at times, plus cut the fellas a break all ready! To bad Castiel can't do some FBI hocus pocus and exponge their record, I'd like that better (or did something like that happen before in an earlier season allready...I can't remember.)
 
white avenger
white avenger
I love the panic room. "You built this?" "Hey, I had a free weekend."
^ Don't know; I've seen up to the end of S2. This Christmas break will be my time to catch up with that.
 
R
Relic
I'll stop before I spoil anything (else) then. Your in for some fun TV :)
J
Joyce Summers
Apologies for SpolierVision!!
From what I've seen, I like it. I only catch ep's every once in a long while, but if I run across it I'm apt to leave it on. It hasn't captivated me like Buffy, but then again nothing else (save Angel) ever has. It's something I'd be interested in enough to buy the DVD's, if I had any money that is.....
 
I've got the first two seasons on DVD and caught a few eps on TV, but have only watched season 1 properly. I really like it and cant compare it to Buffy, they have a different feel to them. I cant wait to watch more but I keep chickening out since I live alone and the wind makes scary noises LOL. I certainly wouldn't say its a kids show, not from what I have seen anyway (and thats not just cos Im a big sook). It sounds like it is only going to get better 🙂
 
B
Blondie Bear
The second season isn't quite as creepy-scary; they're mostly dealing with the demon thing that killed their mom.
Okay, I've got 2 episodes left before I'm completely caught up, and the fourth season is arguably the best one so far. They've got some great writers (many of the lines have me laughing right out loud, most recently, "KNEEL BEFORE TODD!") and the storyline is great. I think that Supernatural might actually replace C.S.I. for my Thursday night viewing this season.
 
R
Relic
It is awsome, now that your caught up we can talk shop about it :)
Definitely a wonderful show! My favorite seasons so far are Seasons 2 and 4! So rich with mythology, so interesting! I love "Roadkill", "Born Under A Bad Sign", "Heart", "All Hell Breaks Loose", "Salvation", "Devil's Trap", "It's A Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester", and many of others from Season 4 SO much. All fantastic eppys :heart: Love this show; can't wait for it to return.
 
Taking this opportunity to insert a very shameless plug here.....😛.....

Our Admin, Buffy Summers has a sister site to the Buffy Boards specifically tailored for the discussion of such shows such as the excellent "Supernatural" currently being discussed in this thread.....among other other horror/sci-fi/fantasy TV shows and movies such as "Smallville", "Doctor Who", "Torchwood", "Fringe", "The Sarah Connors Chronicles", and many more.

It certainly wouldn't be taboo to discuss your respective fan-fave programs and films in there 🙂)), so interested parties should come on over and take a look around. :: tu ::

You are all most welcome at............

After-Darkness - A SciFi Forum
 
B
BlasterBoy606
Thanks! I definitely gotta check this forum out, love those shows!
B
Blondie Bear
I'm there. Thanks!
Hmm, me wonders if I like Supernaturla. *points to AV and sig*

I love this show so very much! There's no way it could replace Buffy and Angel in my heart, but it comes in a definite third. I think it's an amazing miz of comedy and horror, with a little romance thrown in the odd time for good measure.

I certaintly do not see it as a kids show. My sister is about to turn 15 and I don't like her watching some of the episodes. There are defintely a few R rated episodes in there.

My favorite episode of the show, so far, is 'Heart'. It's heart-breaking and beautiful, and Jared and Jensen are amazing in it. 'Heart' was the first episode of Supernatural to make me cry, it made me cry so hard. That's how I know I'm addicted to a show, when it reduces me to a blubbering wreck.
 
B
Blondie Bear
I know! That was so sad!
I'm a big fan of the show. I downloaded the first couple of episodes to see if i'd like it and i took to it straight away so i bought the season 1,2 and 3 boxsets (they were really cheap which was a bonus cause i'm mean with money 😛 ) and i went through them very quickly. Season 4 hasn't hit the UK yet but i've downloaded the first few eps and it's looking good.
 
I liked it but I just began watching it and the season was almost finished so I have to wait for the next one that will come on TV
 
I certaintly do not see it as a kids show. My sister is about to turn 15 and I don't like her watching some of the episodes. There are defintely a few R rated episodes in there.


This season's "Rugaru" episode being one of them. That was pretty disturbing even for a horror movie veteran like me.
 
L
Lou
*makes a note of this for the next time Lyri tells me I should watch it!
Love. This. Show.

At first glance it's similar to Buffy, and as a result the writers often tip their hats to BTVS (the Ghostfacers asking "What Would Buffy Do?" and Kripke and Co. having Amber Bensen and Julie Benz as guest stars) . However, once you get past the unavoidable similarities that come from two television shows focusing on more or less the same thing, Supernatural is really very different. The mood is darker, and the combination of the characters, storylines, filming and music gives it a decidedly rougher feel.

Instead of focusing on someone who was chosen and meant to fight, it focuses on two (three if you include John) guys who do what they do just because it's right. Sam of course has his special abilities story, but it still isn't the same as Buffy's Slayerness. Also, while the focus of Buffy was always her ties to the world and the support group around her, Supernatural focuses highly on the fact that all Sam and Dean have is each other, and Bobby in later seasons. I'd say Kripke has fought hard to make his show different, and I really love it.
 
Lou agrees: *makes a note of this for the next time Lyri tells me I should watch it!

Oi! We're fully grown adults, we can handle a bit o' violence! lol

And what number ep are we talking about? I'm getting to the point were my waiting for the new season to start is slowly moving further and futher away from 'patiently'.
 
^ Sorry Lyri, I keep forgetting you're from the UK.

The episode is Season Four, Episode 4: "Metamorphosis". The story nutshell: Sam and Dean try to help a man who is in danger of transforming into a flesh-eating monster known as a "Rugaru".

You'll love Season four. :: tu ::
 
Lyri
Lyri
*pulls hair out* I can't wait any longer!!
I love Supernatural. I've been watching it since day one. It's nothing like Buffy to me, nor does it seem to ever try to me. The whole style and feel of the show is un-Buffy, and not in a bad way. The acting is a bit cheesy sometimes, but so was the acting on Buffy. Jared Padelecki is my main problem...I don't think his acting is that great, although thankfully it's improved a lot since day one. The show, like any, has its issues, but overall it's very entertaining, and the writing is solid. I love the whole look and feel of the show as well. It's not the best show on TV, but it's definitely one of my favorites.

I can't believe it's not more popular than Smallville...THAT'S a show with completely awful acting, writing, and directing. Yet it's somehow lasted eight seasons, and doesn't look like it's going anywhere for a couple more at least.
 
The only way it's like Buffy is in the S1 ep with the Ghosthunters, when one of them says 'What would Buffy do?' lol
 
The only problems I have with Jared usually come when he's trying to play drunk. The scene in Playthings in Season Two had great dialogue, but I couldn't really take it seriously because Padalecki's acting was so off. There were a few other times, but he's improved greatly since the first season.

I can't believe it's not more popular than Smallville...THAT'S a show with completely awful acting, writing, and directing. Yet it's somehow lasted eight seasons, and doesn't look like it's going anywhere for a couple more at least.

Ugh, I know. If the CW worked half as hard to promote Supernatural as it does Smallville and Gossip Girl, maybe it would get more recognition. I did hear that some of Smallville's more important actors wouldn't be coming back, though, so here's to hoping.
 
I'm very tempted to rent the first season of Supernatural. I've never seen an episode, though I really like Jared Padalecki in Gilmore Girls. (Yes, I know they are complete opposites. 😛) I obviously love paranormal and supernatural shows, but this one seems really scary. 😛

Is it really that scary? And how long does it take to get hooked?
 
Back
Top Bottom