Tabula Rasa vs. Spin the Bottle

[Chosen Enemy]

2 very similar episode ideas, where the gang loses their memories. Both very funny and fun. But which one do you like better?

 

[zobothehobo]

Tabula Rasa. Much funnier and more interesting.

 

[Hale Caesar]

Spin the Bottle, because I like the Fang Gang more than the Scoobies. And it was great to have bumbling Wesley and bitchy Cordelia back, even for one episode 😀

 

[Marisa]

Well what made Tabula Rasa so funny was Spike/Giles thing to me mainly I thought it was funny but I am voting Spin the bottle because I like those characters more and they had funnier moments.

Like Hale Caesar said Cordy and Wesley along with wacky Fred and Angel were pretty darn hilarious.

 

[wickedtiger86]

Tabula Rasa! Made me laugh soo much! It's one of my all time favorites from either show.

 

[AlyInWonderland]

Ooo I think Tabula Rasa. The scene where they go to leave the magic shop and a bunch of demons are outside which causes them to scream like girls is amazing.

 

[Chosen Enemy]

My favorite line from Tabula Rasa is, Spike: "fine! Take those damn spikes!" I don't know why, but that line makes me laugh so hard.

But I think Spin the Bottle is a little, just a little funnier.

 

[sisterofmercy]

I prefer Tabula Rasa but that's because I generally prefer the Scoobies.

 

[xaphania]

I prefer Tabula Rasa, but then I like the characters in BtVS better than AtS.

However the first ten minutes or so of the episode (Willow, Tara, Xander and Anya at dinner) always seem to drag on way too long.

TR also has one of the best Spuffy kisses at the end. 😀

 

[Tranquillity]

I love them both but I voted for Tabula Rasa because I love "Randy and Joan" and Spin the Bottle does have a couple of downer moments interspursed between the hilarity.
The commentary of Spin the Bottle is worth a watch too.

 

[OhWow]

Tabula Rasa. Both are great, but I think I prefer the Scoobies. And Spike just makes that episode incredible.

 

[Taake]

Though I love them both a lot but in the end I went with "Spin the bottle", the teen versions of the AI team are just hilarious in a room together. Angel finding out he's the vampire, Cordy and her hair, Fred and her pot, Wesley period... 🙂 Love it!

 

[Tome]

I have to go with Spin The Bottle. It had me laughing to tears everytime I've watched it... Some scenes are just priceless. 🙂 Tabula Rasa is fun too, but it didn't get me laughing as much.

*shifts back and forth between human and vampire face*... HUH! 😛

 

[November]

I seem to watch Tabula Rasa more tha Spin the Bottle so I think I like it better.

 

[BuffyElevated]

Both episodes are hysterical, but I like "Tabula Rasa" better. I think it's funnier, and- minus the stupidass shark demon- it's better overall.

 

[sosa lola]

Spin the Bottle. It took more risks and had more twists and was much funnier.

 

[Kean]

It's only really the ten minutes in the Magic Box that are funny in Tabula Rasa, whilst Spin the Bottle is much more consistently funny, also we learn a lot about the characters in StB, but I can't really say that about TR.

 

[sosa lola]

It's only really the ten minutes in the Magic Box that are funny in Tabula Rasa, whilst Spin the Bottle is much more consistently funny, also we learn a lot about the characters in StB, but I can't really say that about TR.

I completely agree, the only funny thing about TR was Enya/Rupert/Randy, but the rest were all something I've read in fanfic and wasn't funny at all. Plus they didn't really explore the characters the way AtS did, in a much more interesting way.

 

[Jay Jade]

Spin the Bottle - it was funnier to me...

 

[InsaneMystic]

Spin The Bottle. Not only did I think it a lot funnier than TR, it also lacked the depressing background of Willow mind-raping people again, just a day after promising Tara not to. 🙁