Tara's Death

Do Andrew & Johnathon Deserve To Live

  • Yes

    Votes: 21 67.7%

  • No Kill Them Now !!!!!

    Votes: 11 35.5%
  • Total voters
    31
Johnathon And Andrew didn't kill Tara...Warren did. In fact, there is no evidence that Johnathon and Andrew ever knew what Warren was going to do. They should at least be tried for the death of Warren's girlfriend.
 
They should all pay! I mean...they r all evil little things. Even if Jonathon and Andrew didn't do it...they're still acomplices of Warren's and Warren has done some evil stuff...they went along with his plan when Warren killed that other girl and blamed it on Buffy.

They deserve to pay. I'm really gonna miss Tara.
 
Yes, but there is a difference for killing Warren's girlfriend, which the three plotted to do, and killing Tara, which only one knew of. Secondly, it's not even homicide, more or less accidental homicide--(like when Ted Kennedy drove over that bridge with that girl in it.) Warren was planning to kill Buffy...(wow do I sound like a pre-law geek or what?)
 
I do think that Jonathon and Andrew need to be punished, but i dont think that either Buffy herself or Willow should do it. They should be treated as criminals and dealt with by humans and not by mysical ways. Like Buffy tells dawn in "Two to go".
 
Well i think they should go to prison again or something like that. I mean they didn't killed Tara but they did many other staff for which they should pay.
 
I agree, I don't think they should pay for killing Tara but for hurting all those other people, and not in a magical way, but it a human way.
 
ok dont beat me up...But i think they should live but be punished for what they did....and not for what Warren did...cause Warren did kill tara and like gman said they probably didnt even know warren was going to do that...plus if they were killed that would be like the easy way out...They would never be punished for the crimes they commited and never learn from their mistakes....
 
I agree Lost Slayer. I think that they would actually suffer more if they lived rather than if they died because they'd have so much time to think about what they did. If they die, then the pain doesn't last for very long.
 
They should live, but I think karma should come back to bite them in the ass. They seemed more soulful then Warren ever was and they weren't the people who killed Tara. Warren did it and he got what he deserved.
 
No, kill them NOW! I am so sick of Johnathen and Andrew and his closet gayness was very annoying. Slower and more painful death than Warren, I say. Well, for Andrew at least. Johnathen gets a break since he did try to help out a little. Kill him fast. 😀
 
I don't think either Jonathan or Andrew deserves to die. In fact, keep them around for a long long time - they were funny.

Andrew was just a hapless groupie to Warren. He didn't do anything bad because that's what he wanted, he did it because he knew it would please Warren if he did. Like so many people in this great wide world of ours, he was a sheep. Baah.

Jonathan knew that alot of things he was doing were wrong, but he was threatened and intimidated by big bad Warren. He even was on to the scheme that he was being used and would end up being killed or left for dead or turned over to the police and blamed for the things Warren did. Unlike Andrew's sheep, Jonathan was the scape-goat. Neeh.

So, you see the critters shouldn't be killed.

Whether Andrew comes back or not is a moot point, but PLEASE bring Jonathan back - he's been on the series from the very beginning and needs to stay until the very very end.
 
Originally posted by gman992
Johnathon And Andrew didn't kill Tara...Warren did. In fact, there is no evidence that Johnathon and Andrew ever knew what Warren was going to do. They should at least be tried for the death of Warren's girlfriend.
Click to expand...

I agree with gman, they don't deserve to die. They didn't even do anything to anyone. Warren killed Tara and he got his in the end.
It was a tragic event and she will be missed.
 
i think because this is buffy land they should be sent to some other dimension where they will quite literally get the punishment they deserve
ie a magical punishment for magical/mystical crimes
but i also agreee with what some of you have said
i really dont think they should die
cause how is that really making anything right
so they should just be punished in a noon dying kind of way
 
I didn't see the epi yet, but when I sa 'tara's death' I paniced,
and i voted immidiately for 'kill them now'
I don't know if they killed her or not (how could i know, didn't see the epi yet...)
 
Andrew is annoying but he was just a follower. I don't think either he or Jonathon meant for Katrina to die but they did cover it up and that should be punished. Jonathon should be redeamed and help buffy in some way but I don't think Willow will ever forgive him for being in the group!!
 
I don't know about anyone else, but as a horror genre show, the episode where Tara was shot is the first time I have really been scared by the show. There is slaying all the time, but only of Vampires and Demons, not in a human way and not with guns. They have created a mystical universe on Buffy where guns seldom exist and that makes Tara's murder so much more shocking. (Oh alright, the Gentlemen scared me a little too but in a totally different way.)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom