The Creepiest Puppet on BTVS/Angel

[Valjavertjinn]

As some of you may know, I have issues with Muppets and Puppets. (Yuppets I can handle.) Anyways, I was wondering what you guys thought was the creepiest or scariest or weirdest muppet on Angel or Buffy.
There is Puppet Angel,

his "Smile Time" buddies,

Sid (he's the one on the left 😛),

and the OMWF... puppet-people.

I personally am terrified of all of them, but the "Smile Time" Muppets were the WORST. All gangly and floppy and... fuzzy. Ick.

(And it was not traumatic in any way for me to find these pictures. Nope. Nuh-uh. *Twitches*)

 

[Skytteflickan88]

Sid. Not only did he creep me out before we found out he was a good guy, his personality was creepy as well. He just seems like a douche.

Puppet Angel is adorable. Really loved puppet Spike and puppet Lorne in the comic series Shadow Puppets.

 

[Ripper666]

I go for Sid too because he is scary and the hole episode with him was full of voltage and confusion! And I have to think about Chaos Bleeds. In the Buffy fan video game you can play Sid too! That was amazing!
Sid, Sid, Sid...such a great scary puppet!

 

[brinkster130]

Sid was beyond creepy. His looks and the things he said just gave me the willies.

 

[EvilBuffy]

My first thought was Sid because I'm usually very disturbed by ventriloquist dummies but I was a bit more creeped out by the Smile Time puppets.

 

[Taake]

Sid, a thousand times Sid.
The puppet people from OMWF come in at a close second but Sid just sends chills down my spine.... :S

 

[Living Dead Boy]

I don't think any one of those puppets are creepy. My favorite is Sid, because he's supposed to be the one behind the murders and he was set up to be all scary but in an amazing twist, he was the good guy. And a hilarious one at that. I don't find him creepy, I find him cool as hell.

 

[BuffyElevated]

Sid. Not only did he creep me out before we found out he was a good guy, his personality was creepy as well. He just seems like a douche.

YES.... Sid creeped me out, even after I found out he was "good". His pedophile comments toward Buffy? Sick.