The Scoobies VS The Fang Gang

[VisionGuy]

Just for fun,who do you think would win if there was ever a showdown between the two?

Buffy vs Angel
Xander vs Conner
Willow vs Illyria
Giles vs Wesley
Dawn vs Fred
Anya vs Cordelia
Tara vs Harmony
Riley vs Spike
Oz vs Gunn
Andrew vs Lorne

Buffy vs Angel I think Buffy would win.I mean she has beaten him before in "Becoming"
Xander vs Conner Poor Xander would get his butt kicked.Unless he brought along the construction truck he used in "The Gift".
Willow vs Illyria Willow would win but it would be a tough one to decide if Illyria is at full power.
Giles vs Wesley If it was hand to hand,Wesley would beat.If it's with magic Giles would be the winner.
Dawn vs Fred This is a tough one since none of them really fight much.I really don't think they'd fight at all.They probably would sit down and talk about their experiences: Dawn being the key and Fred being stuck in Pylea for five years.
Anya vs Cordelia Cordelia would win since she has the fighting experience thanks to Angel.If Anya were to be a vengeance demon she would beat poor Cordy with her super strength.
Tara vs Harmony I think Tara would win thanks to her magic.Also Harmony's not much of a fighter.Think back to the girly fight she and Xander had in BtVS season 4.
Riley vs Spike Spike would definetly beat Riley.The only reason Spike let Riley push him around is because ha had the chip.
Oz vs Gunn Gunn would win since he has all the streetfighting experience.If Oz were a werewolf it would be a tough call.
Andrew vs Lorne Lorne would win if he brought his gun.If not,they'd probably smack each other around for a few minutes until they got tired.

Those are my results.Tell me yours.

 

[Eternie]

Buffy vs Angel: Buffy. As has been said, she kicked his arse once, she can do it again.
Xander vs Connor: (Connor, not Conner)... Connor would win from pure strength, though Xander would put up a good fight.
Willow vs Illyria: Oh wow... well it'd all depend what time period the dudes are at and as Illyria's only around when Willow is superstrong I'd bet on Willow. Unless Illyria used her time slowing trick. Tis a conundrum.
Giles vs Wesley: Giles without a doubt. Unless Wesley had his sneaky weapons.
Dawn vs Fred: Fred would beat Dawn without any problem at all. Go Fred.
Anya vs Cordelia: Cordelia, but I think Anya would hold her own for a while. Unless this was season three Buffy with Anya a slightly dumb newly humaned thing and Cordelia a brat. Then Anya would win.
Tara vs Harmony: Tara. So, so easily. But I also think she wouldn't fight her willingly.
Riley vs Spike: Spike, but only because I like him more.
Oz vs Gunn: Oz. Post-Buffy Oz definitely. He wolfs when he gets mad. No idiot would pick a fight with him. Though in general punchups I'd think Gunn because no only is he trained, he's twice the size of Oz.
Andrew vs Lorne: Lorne can kick arse when he wants to.

 

[Amber Benson]

Buffy vs Angel - Buffy... Duh, shes Buffy!
Xander vs Conner - Poor innocent Xander... But I do believe Connor would win...
Willow vs Illyria - I think it would be close, but Willow would pull throught with the Wicca power..
Giles vs Wesley - I think Wesley would win, but only because he is entirely too weapon happy 😛
Dawn vs Fred - I can't even see a fight going on there...
Anya vs Cordelia - Hmm... Close, but I think Anya...
Tara vs Harmony - Tara... All the way, with the Magicks and her "axing" abilities 😛
Riley vs Spike - Without his chip, Spike no doubt...
Oz vs Gunn - Gunn... Oz is weak... Weak Oz!
Andrew vs Lorne - Again, don't see too much fighting... Get on with the baking and talking

 

[WatcherWes]

I think Angel would beat Buffy. She had soooo much trouble with Caleb and oh yeah, Angel knocked him flat on his ass with two punches. Add in that Angel has had way more battles in the last few years, and that ups his combat skills considerably.

 

[eponinethen]

Buffy vs Angel: Buffy.. Not an easy choice for me but I'd say Buffy..
Xander vs Connor: Connor, lol, definitely
Willow vs Illyria: I know nothing about Illyria so I'll say Willow (dark Willow)
Giles vs Wesley: Hmm.. Giles.. I think..
Dawn vs Fred: Definitely Fred..
Anya vs Cordelia: Well, unless Anya was Anyanka (which I'm guessing she wasn't) Cordelia would beat her
Tara vs Harmony: Harmony.. Tara's got the magic thing but I don't think she knows a lot of that kind of magic.. Harmony is a vampire after all..
Riley vs Spike: Spike for sure, vampire strenght, plus he's cooler
Oz vs Gunn: Gunn.. no doubt about that..
Andrew vs Lorne: Lorne..

 

[Destructo Girl]

Buffy vs Angel- Buffy, yeah definitely. She's done it before so why couldn't she do it again?
Xander vs Conner- Connor. Yeah, sorry Xand, love ya, but you'd get your arse kicked.
Willow vs Illyria- Willow. Dark or otherwise. She'd kick blue booty.
Giles vs Wesley-Angel Wesley would win. Buffy Wesley would lose.
Dawn vs Fred- Hmmm, Dawn, I guess, she did get trained by Buffy...
Anya vs Cordelia- Anya, just cause. 🙂
Tara vs Harmony-Tara. She's all magicky. She'd find a way! 😉
Riley vs Spike- Hahahahahahahaha...this is any actual question? Spike, for sure
Oz vs Gunn-Gunn. Yepp.
Andrew vs Lorne - Andrew. He'd hit Lorne once and then run. Which is technically winning (😉) in my book anyway

 

[Xin Rong]

Buffy vs Angel - Buffy... Buffy as we know she's stroner nad has beaten him before- i wpould prefer angel to win though
Xander vs Conner - 100% Connor, Xander wouldn't really stand a chance
Willow vs Illyria - Post drainage of Illyrias power Willow would win but pre drainage i dont think willow would win but she'd put up a better fight than anyone else could
Giles vs Wesley - I'd say Giles- more experience
Dawn vs Fred - Dawn although Fred does seem to have a good punch
Anya vs Cordelia - Cordy.. anyas not that tough
Tara vs Harmony - Tara as harmony's not really a fighter and Tara is pretty powerful her
Riley vs Spike - Spike, riley couldn't win a fight with a daisy
Oz vs Gunn - Gunn would so win as I cant see Oz being that good a fighter
Andrew vs Lorne - Lorne he has that high pitched screaming thing although andy does seem goo at annoying people in the show lol maybe he could annoy lorne to death

 

[DáNió]

Buffy vs Angel - Buffy... there probably both equally strong.. but Buff's got more stamina
Xander vs Conner - Conner.. hes the son of vampires.. he kicked Xanders butt
Willow vs Illyria - ahh a toughie.. in the end probably Illyria
Giles vs Wesley - Wesley.. he has all his gadgety tools
Dawn vs Fred - another toughie.. I think neither really..
Anya vs Cordelia - Anya defiently.. turn into a total bitch fight
Tara vs Harmony - Tara.. shes all witchy
Riley vs Spike - Spike.. he would kick the sod's ass in to gear
Oz vs Gunn - urmm.. werewolf oz would win.. but Gunn..
Andrew vs Lorne - tehe.. that would be funny.. probably Lorne.. andrew would probaly start whinning..

 

[WatcherWes]

How would Buffy have more stamina? She's got to respirate, and as the fight progressed, she'd be breathing harder and harder. Angel isn't breathing at all. Regardless of who you think would win, Buffy having more stamina seems wrong.

 

[SlayerThe]

Buffy vs Angel - Easily Buffy. First because a slayer was created far stronger than vampires and secondly just because it's Buffy. She's taken down the Master and countless other deadly foes, not to mention that she is far more agile and, as stated before, has more stamina/endurance. She may be mortal, but she's Buffy and she always wins.
Xander vs Conner Conner easily, kid's amazingly strong.
Willow vs Illyria Illyria when at full power. Willow at any other time.
Giles vs Wesley Giles. Wesley may have been tough during the last few seasons of Angel, but Giles is the man.
Dawn vs Fred Fred, only because she would create some device to help her out.
Anya vs CordeliaCordelia. Don't mess with CC.
Tara vs HarmonyTara. Hard choice though.
Riley vs Spike Spike. Easily.
Oz vs Gunn Gunn. Another easy choice.
Andrew vs Lorne Lorne, well when he has to...

 

[LadyLavinia]

[Buffy vs Angel - Buffy, hands down. Angel always seemed to have trouble with Slayers.

Xander vs Conner - Connor, easily.

Willow vs Illyria - tough call. Cannot decide. Physically, Illyria is stronger. But magically? Tough call.

Giles vs Wesley - Another tough call. Although Giles is the more experienced fighter, Wesley has improved a lot over the years.

Dawn vs Fred - Season 7 Dawn against Season 5 Fred? Dawn, hands down.

Anya vs Cordelia - Anya.

Tara vs Harmony - Harmony. Sorry Tara, but Harmony's fighting skills have improved and she is a vampire.

Riley vs Spike - Spike without a chip. Hands down. Why is Spike listed with the Fang Gang and not the Scoobies?
Oz vs Gunn - If Oz was a werewolf . . . tough call. I don't know. Gunn is a very experienced demon hunter.

Andrew vs Lorne - Andrew. Better at magic.

 

[Primal Slayer]

Buffy vs. Angel- Buffy ofcourse, she has kicked his butt before, even when he was evil and it was all out war between the two so it wouldnt be hard.
Xander vs. Conner- Conner obviously, far more experiance in fighting and well the whole super streangth thing helps to.
Willow vs. Illyria- toughie. Illyria would have to get her hands on willow in order to win since Willow would kick her butt in the magic department. I saw draw
Giles vs. Wesley- Giles, Wes may be tough but Giles has basicaly been since day one and its taken Wesley a couple of years to get to where Teenage Giles was.
Dawn vs. Fred- Dawn, deffinatly. She has fighting experiance and has trained with Buffy, and I think Dawn is smart enough to keep Fred from her element, and well its kind of hard to build a device while fighting.
Anya vs. Cordelia- I have to say Anya, since it looks like Anya was just putting on a weak girl ploy upto Season7 since we saw how she handled herself with Spike and Buffy, sure she mightve been a demon but she could still fight.
Tara vs. Harmony- Harmony, perky vampress who is somewhat good at figthing, and Tara is just to nice.
Riley vs. Spike- Spike obviously
Oz vs. Gunn- Gunn would win, Oz was never a figther while he was on the show.
Andrew vs. Lorne- draw, they would sit down to a cup of tea or something. But Lorne would probabyl win with his voice. Andrew would probably say something like "how very Darth Vader of you"
Scoobies vs. Fang Gang in all out war- The Scoobies would win, they have better team work and trust each other better, whereas the Fang Gang, one of them is always trying to kill the other it seems and well with trust...

 

[WatcherWes]

So Buffy's the slayer. Big deal. Angel's taken Faith, Dana and fought Buffy to a standstill several times. Consider also how far Angel's come since the fight in Becoming. A century in hell, and then 5 years fighting demons, vamps, busting into demon dimensions and oh yeah, fighting Jasmine, a frigging Higher Power.

 

[Primal Slayer]

So Buffy's the slayer. Big deal. Angel's taken Faith, Dana and fought Buffy to a standstill several times. Consider also how far Angel's come since the fight in Becoming. A century in hell, and then 5 years fighting demons, vamps, busting into demon dimensions and oh yeah, fighting Jasmine, a frigging Higher Power.

And Buffy has beaten Angel before, The Master, Spike and Dru, The Mayor, Faith, Adam, Glory a hell god, been to hell for an hour, been to heaven, demons, vamps, evil willow, anya, kendra, sunday, dracula himself.

 

[Cookie Dough]

And Buffy has beaten Angel before, The Master, Spike and Dru, The Mayor, Faith, Adam, Glory a hell god, been to hell for an hour, been to heaven, demons, vamps, evil willow, anya, kendra, sunday, dracula himself.

Some of those people she didn't kill though or she had help.

 

[DáNió]

Riley vs Spike - Spike without a chip. Hands down. Why is Spike listed with the Fang Gang and not the Scoobies?

I do believe that Spike was with the 'Fang Gang' in S5..

 

[Tainted Hope]

Buffy vs Angel Angel. Hands down, now. He's gotten alot better after they last fought. You know what, I change my mind. Buffy, really.
Xander vs Conner As much as it pains me to say this- Conner. Major fighty mojo going on.
Willow vs Illyria Hmm... methinks Illyria, with her oldy but goldy
Giles vs Wesley Giles. Hands down.
Dawn vs Fred Uber smart Fred, hands down.
Anya vs Cordelia Cordelia can kick ass- so of course, she'd beat Anya. Unless Anya was, ya know, a demon.
Tara vs Harmony Pshaw, Tara.
Riley vs Spike Spike! Duh!
Oz vs Gunn Gunn, of course.
Andrew vs Lorne Eh... I dunno..

I just noticed that I put "Hands down" alot...

 

[Primal Slayer]

Some of those people she didn't kill though or she had help.

you dont need to kill something to be victorius, she still beat some of them to a bloody pulp(Glory for instance) and Angel has had help with going up against some of his enemies as well.

 

[Wesley's Sylyna]

Buffy vs Angel Buffy, she's the slayer and if it came down to it Angel would be dust in the wind.

Xander vs Conner Hmmmmm. Xander, ok Conner's got that superhuman strength that he got from his parents but he never seamed that smart.
Xander on the other hand knows how to plan and fall thur with it. It would be a close finish but Xander would win.

Willow vs Illyria Willow, duh! Illyria maybe an old one (whatever that means), buy Willow's got all that magic.
The fact that she could have kicked Glory's ass shows it.

Giles vs Wesley Not even going to go there, I don't even want them to argue.

Dawn vs Fred Dawn, Fred is not the good of a fighter, I see her as more of a hair puller.

Anya vs Cordelia Cordelia! Anya maybe over a thousand years old but she didn't learn that much during that time.

Tara vs Harmony Cat-fight, *giggles* sorry had to do that, ok I'm going to say Tara. Tara, a witch vs. Harmony, a vampire equals one pail of dust and one pissed off witch (over Harmony biting Willow).

Riley vs Spike Spike, even if this is after him being chipped. Spike is way smarter that Riley.

Oz vs Gunn Oz, Gunn maybe a good fighter but you cannot get away from a werewolf unless you have a tranquilizer gun or real one.

Andrew vs Lorne Lorne!!!!!!

 

[Lee]

Buffy vs Angel - Hmmmm, I'd have to go with Buffy beatin' Angel's.
Xander vs Conner - Conner, without a doubt - Xander wouldnt even be able to get a punch in...
Willow vs Illyria - Depends which kind of Willow and Illyria we're talking. If its Super-Wicka vs. Fully Powered Demoness, then I think Darth Rosenberg would be victorious...buuuut, if it was normal Willow and powered-down Illyria, then I think Illyria beat Willow.
Giles vs Wesley - Hmmmm, hard to say really...it would *definitely* be Giles if we're talking clumbsy-funny Wesley...but hmmm...I dunno...I still think I'd go with Giles...
Dawn vs Fred - Urgh, Fred would kick Dawn's ass!!
Anya vs Cordelia - So far, most people have chosen Cordelia over Anya....buut, I really think Anya would win - look at The Gift, Older and Far Away and Chosen - she kicked butt! So yah, I chose Anya, so there! 😛
Tara vs Harmony - Harmony...I love Tara, but just Harmony...
Riley vs Spike - Chipless Spike woulda lost, Soulless Spike woulda won, Souled Spike woulda won, lol...
Oz vs Gunn - Gunn, either with Were-Oz or human-Oz, Gunn wins...
Andrew vs Lorne - lol! *Flashes back to the Xander/Harmony 'fight'* < Probably go something like that...but I reckon Lorne would win...stoopid wimpy Andrew!