When i first saw this, i was alot younger and i was more excited at seeing it then actually critiquing it....so now i will.
How bloomin awful...LOL.
No, thats not fair, but it was pretty harsh going.
First of all though, I gotta give Kudos to Michelle Geller. She actually played Buffy in that better then most of season 1..also she was still hot.
Not that she isn't an attractive lady now, its just she is a little slimmer then what I prefer.
Nic Brendon did a similar job to what we saw in the 'School Yard Years', though his acting was a little hammy with the reveal of Buffy as the Slayer......but then he often 'hammed it up' in the show too.
Riff Regan....oh my Lordy-Lou. Who here wishes to pray to God with me in thanx for the Birth of Alyson Hannigan!!!!
I have always appreciated her shy, timid but loyal and strong Willow but this pilot has made me appreciate her so much more.
In comparison to Michelle Gellar and Brendan(great and 'hammy') this girl was terribly stiff and wooden....and i'm sorry but the idea that the 'Chuncky Monkey' would dispose of Darla so easily(I know that was only for the purposes of the Pilot but still) 'grinds my gears'.
I suppose that for the wrong reasons the studio execs made the right choice.
By that, I do mean that they shouldn't have gotten rid of Riff because she was on the Chubby side.....they should have on the basic premise that she was shit!.
Stewart Heads Performance was as impeccible as ever, it was just as you'd imagine from a seasoned actor, so can't really say much, same with Carpenter, pretty similar to what you expected.
Next, something I actually forgot about this but the Principle.
Oh MY GOSH why didn't they keep Stephen Tobolowsky. That guy was SOOOO funny as Flutie. Ok Lerner was amusing, but Tobolowsky has had roles in some of my fave movies, including Groundhog Day and SPACEBALLS.
Man, he was a treat, i genuinely believed his characterization and his 'Bunny', 'Bambi', 'Betty', 'Wilma' stuff was not only really funny, but believeable.
OK, one final note to mention. Mercedes McNab. I personally find it quite interesting(in just basic trivia kinda of way) that with the exception of no one, she is the only one to have been in from the very beginning of Buffy to the Very end of Angel.
Granted she wasn't in every episode and Boreanaz joined the first aired episode, but MM is the only one from the beginning to the end(not including the movie).
OK, on that, i'll just say that there was enough to enjoy on a certain level, and the humour of the show was evident, but gotta question, on the strength of that pilot, does anyone think that now this show would not have made the air?
OK, thanks and i'll go now🙂