Wait A Second...Haven't We Seen This Before?

Kana

Soulless human
Joined
Oct 15, 2007
Messages
1,305
Ok I'm sure you guys have noticed that Mr Whedon likes to use common plot and character devices and parallels. So inspired by the TV Tropes website, I'm going to try and identity some of these devices and common themes that tend to, how shall we say, repeat themselves! I'll put the common theme/ archtype etc in bold and underline and place examples and explanation below.

Father's Suck

Pretty obvious this one. The examples? Take your pick. Buffy's dad goes from attentive weekend dad to deadbeat dad in a matter of like, a season. Xander's parents both seem pretty bad but the father seems worse. Where is Willow's Dad? Wes' dad is kind of a jerk and the list goes on...

Redemption

Angel, Spike, Faith, Willow, Jonathan made at least an attempt.

This follows....

I like to kill things

Angel and Spike, Andrew, Willow, Faith, Giles, Gunn, Fred more or less attempted to murder Siedel. Justine's attempted murder and Holtz' attempted murder.

Sex is Evil

Bangel sex usually leads to heartbreak of some sort (and sometimes the end of the world, literally). Giles having sex is a sign is at a loose end. Cordy has safe sex and still ends up pregnant, with demon spawn no less. Spuffy sex was linked to Buffy indulging in self-loathing and ended in attempted rape. Like, the whole episode of Lonely Hearts.

Supposed To Be Nerdy But Clearly Hot

Putting Willow in bad clothes doesn't make her unattractive. She's, hot end of story. Buffy criticizing Wes' looks was annoying. He's clearly a hottie. Just an uptight, nerdy hottie. Xander's clearly buff as well.

Where Do I Fit?

Xander on Btvs and Gunn on Ats.

Anya. Cordy Mark 2?

So Xander goes out with a beautiful, albeit materialistic girl, who is extremely blunt and self-centred but ends being incredibly brave, then does it again.

Spike. Angel Mark 2?

Although these two aren't totally the same, they certainly have a lot in common.

1. Both had strong parental figures whose words haunted them well into the future.
2. Both of them have the same given name: Liam and William.
3. Both of them are sired by beautiful vampiresses who saw their potential despite it not being all that obvious.
4. Following on from that, the meek and shy William became violent, loud and changed his upper class accent to a working class accent. Liam who was a drunken layabout became a artistic intelletual and his horrid Irish accent remained.
5. Dru.
6. Both had to adapt after external forces rendered them less of a monster than before (Angelus' soul and Spike's chip)
7. And then the love of a Slayer inspired them to become champions.
8. Long leather jackets
9. Weird hair.

Evil Establishment, I Rebuke Thee

Any establishment that is generally depicted as some form of authority, our heroes generally rebel against. In Btvs, it's the Watcher's Council, Initiative on Ats, it's Wolfram and Hart

Holtz Sounds Like The German Word For "Wood''

Both Wood and Holtz had their family members killed by a vampire who is now no longer evil, yet they go after them anyway (another parallel for Spike and Angel)

"It's The Other One"

Buffy is the original Slayer. Now there is only suppose to be one Slayer, but then along comes another one, Faith. At first Buffy feel threatened by the arrival of the new Slayer and Faith starts to feel jealous of the Buffy. Buffy also sees Faith as outgoing and a little reckless as she is more reserved and careful. Their rivalry culminates in a huge fight with one coming close to killing the other. However in the end, they push through their differences and fight side by side.

If you replace "Buffy" with "Angel", "Faith" with "Spike" and "Slayer" with "Vampire With a Soul" then you get a similar effect.

__________________________________________________________________________

There are others but I'll let you guys post first. So what do you think? Are their any other parallels you've seen, or common devices or patterns that repeat themselves? Granted, some of these aren't exclusive to the Buffyverse but if it repeats itself, it's going in...
 
^^ At least Angel never had a lame-ass chip in his head that made him comedic relief...OH SNAP

LMFAO Ooooh...

Yeah there are a lot of themes that carry through both shows. Seems to me that Joss has a lot of issues that come out in his writing. LOL
 
LOL I see similarities in Spike/Angel and the way they were both evil to me no one is better because they both were bad. Angel can be funny but Spike has to be number one.
 
This is a nicely thought out analysis. I enjoyed reading it.

Although Angel and Spike seem quite different from each other, they definitely both have weird hair.

Also one of Whedon's tendencies: He always seems to give his characters strange names. Does anyone else notice that?
 
WillowForEver
WillowForEver
[No message]
Kana
Kana
[No message]
Boring, Awkward, Nerdy, Bookworms become Bad***

Giles, Willow, Fred, Wesley...

Lovable Female Character Struggles with Sanity

Tara, Fred, River, Drusilla (okay not so lovable)
 
T
ticonderouga
Buffy in the institution
Kana
Kana
Good catches
I'd also add the mystical family:

Dawn, made out of Buffy.
Connor, made out of non-fertiles people.


It was a great read, thank for sharing your analysis 😀
 
The family of circumstance,

As in groups who form a tight familial bond with people they are not related to and are together mostly by circumstance. This plays out not only in AtS and BtVS but also in Fire Fly and Dollhouse as well.
 
Sex is Evil
Where the Wild Things Are

Where Do I Fit?
Anya as well

Spike. Angel Mark 2?
Both killed their parents because they were ridiculed by them.
 
T
Tammy
[No message]
Kana
Kana
[No message]
M
Ms.Trick
[No message]
Sex is Evil

Bangel sex usually leads to heartbreak of some sort (and sometimes the end of the world, literally). Giles having sex is a sign is at a loose end. Cordy has safe sex and still ends up pregnant, with demon spawn no less. Spuffy sex was linked to Buffy indulging in self-loathing and ended in attempted rape. Like, the whole episode of Lonely Hearts.
..

You also forgot Xander's first time with Faith followed by an attempt rape/murder. And Willow and Tara getting back together and spending the whole day having sex and next day Tara is killed. Sex is totally evil. 😛

Xander being a dateless nerd has always shocked me. Most of the people I know who watched the show said, "I'd totally date him if he was in my school." He's buff and tall and handsome.
 
M
Ms.Trick
I agree! And those abs! And he's funny. I'd totally date him :D Him being unpopular is not believable.
Supposed To Be Nerdy But Clearly Hot

Putting Willow in bad clothes doesn't make her unattractive. She's, hot end of story.

Not sure about that one... 😉 Sorry Goby!! Maybe in s6-7. I agree that Xander didn't look nerdy at all, tho.

Anya and Cordy are not the same, psh. 😛 As for ''fathers suck''... I think it's more ''parents suck''. Aside from Joyce(at times) and Fred's parents, I don't remember any of their parents being shown in a bright light(if they were even mentioned, see Gunn, Spike's father, Faith's father ect)...

Spike. Angel Mark 2?

Although these two aren't totally the same, they certainly have a lot in common.

1. Both had strong parental figures whose words haunted them well into the future.
2. Both of them have the same given name: Liam and William.
3. Both of them are sired by beautiful vampiresses who saw their potential despite it not being all that obvious.
4. Following on from that, the meek and shy William became violent, loud and changed his upper class accent to a working class accent. Liam who was a drunken layabout became a artistic intelletual and his horrid Irish accent remained.
5. Dru.
6. Both had to adapt after external forces rendered them less of a monster than before (Angelus' soul and Spike's chip)
7. And then the love of a Slayer inspired them to become champions.
8. Long leather jackets
9. Weird hair.
Right on! 😉
 
I'd also add the mystical family:

Dawn, made out of Buffy.
Connor, made out of non-fertiles people.


It was a great read, thank for sharing your analysis 😀

Good catch. Adding to that, both of them whine about how they shouldn't have existed.

sosa lola said:
You also forgot Xander's first time with Faith followed by an attempt rape/murder. And Willow and Tara getting back together and spending the whole day having sex and next day Tara is killed. Sex is totally evil.

There were a few more I could have included, but I didn't want my OP to be too long, but good spot.

Xander being a dateless nerd has always shocked me. Most of the people I know who watched the show said, "I'd totally date him if he was in my school." He's buff and tall and handsome

Buff he is.

To add to the list:

My Surrogate Daddy Is a Psychopath

Ok so he is your father figure or mentor. He seems polite, kind and but he's actually an evil SOB. Cue the Mayor. Another similar character is Holland Manners.
 
Characters That Share Some of the Same Traits

Buffy, Angel, Mal, Echo (leaders)

Giles, Wesley, Boyd, Adele, Shepherd Book (experience and brains behind the operation)

Willow, Fred, Kaylee (lovable, innocent, genius)

Cordelia, Spike, Anya,Jayne, Faith (challenge the hero's authority, no filter, anti-hero)

Inara, Tara (nurturing, sexuality creates some unwarranted controversy)

Riley, Ballard (ex-military, trying to cope with unnatural world)

Xander, Wash (lovable support sidekick who is often unappreciated and whose contributions are often underestimated.)

Dawn, River, Conner (powerful teen everyone is trying to protect)
 
There is also the "one person we kinda trusted the whole season turned on us" in most seasons of Buffy.

Season 2: Angel is good during half the season then becomes Angelus
Season 3: Faith is on the good side of the force for about half the season before she goes completely dark.
Season 4: Well, I can't say we can trust him, but the Scoobies got used to Spike being harmless, and then in the end of the season he pulled a Spike on them.
Season 5: Ben starts as the good guy and gets more and more tortured so he becomes untrustable and decides not to help Dawn.
Season 6: Good old Willow goes mad in a relatively controlled way before going completely Evil Bitca at the end of the season.


And in Angel:

Season 2: Angel goes nuts (without being Angelus)
Season 3: Wesley betrays Angel
Season 4: Cordy gets possessed and thereby
Season 5: Harmony betrays Angel (again, we just *kinda* trusted her, but that wasn't a big surprise)
 
Last edited:
C
caritas08
good point
Kana
Kana
well spotted
Back
Top Bottom