He had a chance in "Lover's Walk." I think killing Willow, or turning her into a vampire, would have magically dissolved his plot armor, for sure. Forget Buffy, I'm imagining what Xander would have done to him!
I'm imagining Xander reducing Spike to ash, then stomping on the ash, then sweeping up the ash and flushing it down the toilet.Xander "Rocket Launcher" Harris? Or Xander "Say Hi to My Wrecking Ball" Harris?
The only reason Spike would not have been a bloody smear is because vampires do not leave smears.
Whichever she could get her hands on. I think both would be shocked by how powerful rage makes a.Slayer.I'm contemplating a much more serious question, had Spike's girlfriend got jealous over Spike being the sire of Willow and attacked Willow,
which one would Buffy have chosen to go up against first?