What if Tara came back as a Whitelighter?

Willow My Love said:
Her death is final. If Willow got to see her again, even as an angel, I feel it would detract from what Osiris told her, and from the severe effect Tara's death had on Willow.
Click to expand...
How so? She'd still be dead, and they'd still be seperated. Osiris said that Tara couldn't be resurrected and she wouldn't have been, she would've moved on and ascended. It's not the same thing.
 
Dagenspear said:
How so? She'd still be dead, and they'd still be seperated. Osiris said that Tara couldn't be resurrected and she wouldn't have been, she would've moved on and ascended. It's not the same thing.
Click to expand...

Dude. It's my opinion that it would subtract from her death. I've said it three time in three different ways, and I'm done repeating myself.
 
Willow My Love said:
Dude. It's my opinion that it would subtract from her death. I've said it three time in three different ways, and I'm done repeating myself.
Click to expand...
Wow. No need for the harshness. You just killed my buzz. I kinda wanna cry now.

---------- Post added at 01:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:03 AM ----------

And that wasn't sarcasm, just so you know.
 
I don't see how that's so harsh to make you want to cry. I did state my opinion multiple times, and I don't feel like repeating myself again.My response was curt, yes. Rude? No.
 
I will of course agree to disagree but I felt there was something I'd like to add 🙂

Dagenspear said:
How so? She'd still be dead, and they'd still be seperated. Osiris said that Tara couldn't be resurrected and she wouldn't have been, she would've moved on and ascended. It's not the same thing.
Click to expand...

In my opinion they wouldn't be separated if she was a whitelighter. If we go by the Charmed definition of Whitelighters (I don't believe I've seen them elsewhere and I believe these were the kind suggested at the start of the thread) then they are not at all separated from humans. Perhaps it's not recommended that they co-mingle too much but they are flesh and blood beings, human in every sense except for being immortal, more than once do we see them engage in intimate relationships with other humans so had Tara returned as a whitelighter she and Willow could have resumed their relationship with no other obstacles than perhaps emotional ones.
 
Taake said:
In my opinion they wouldn't be separated if she was a whitelighter. If we go by the Charmed definition of Whitelighters (I don't believe I've seen them elsewhere and I believe these were the kind suggested at the start of the thread) then they are not at all separated from humans. Perhaps it's not recommended that they co-mingle too much but they are flesh and blood beings, human in every sense except for being immortal, more than once do we see them engage in intimate relationships with other humans so had Tara returned as a whitelighter she and Willow could have resumed their relationship with no other obstacles than perhaps emotional ones.
Click to expand...
Isn't that forbidden though? I forget.
 
Dagenspear said:
Isn't that forbidden though? I forget.
Click to expand...

Oh yes it is forbidden, yet we see Whitelighters breaking that rule with no greater repercussions (Sam and Leo are the first that come to mind but I might be omitting a few due to poor memory). Even the ghosts of their mother and grandmother return to bodily form at special times though. (Though technically I guess that only implies that Charmed isn't that strict on their own rules 🙂)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom