What was the saddest part of The Body?

Status
Not open for further replies.

The Ferg

Scooby
Joined
Apr 7, 2008
Messages
1,366
Location
Omaha, NE
Ok, first off, this kinda seems really creepy, weird, and... well... awkward ::huh1::, but I was just wondering because for one, this episode was brilliant. And for two, I thought it would be fun to see what make other people... tick.

Imo, it was when Buffy said, "They said not to touch the body!" I literally broke down.
 
S
sibby
I cried at this...
For me its when she first see's joyce lying there and just says 'mommy...'
This episode really does hit home and i dont watch it that much but it is a stunning piece of television.
 
For me it's Dawn's breakdown at school, Buffy's 'mommy...', and Willow with her clothing problem. And also, it was the atmosphere in general. Normally you got music playing in the background to get into what ever mood, but in this episode it was just silence.
 
Yeah, I know. I think that was the beauty of the episode right? Joss doesn't need music to make a great episode.
 
While I've never been an Anya fan... I'd have to say that her speech in this episode about her misunderstanding of death is the part that gets me. Thinking about the fact that someone won't get to do anything ever again is what makes death sad.
 
For Me Its Definalty When Buffy Says "The Told Us Not To Touch The Body".............
And Anya's Breakdown I Just Feel Really bad That She Doesnt Understand and Everyone is Coming Down On Her
 
Angelic Slayer
Angelic Slayer
[No message]
Btvs is so unusual and weird for a tv show, that when something normal happens like this its like...WHAT!
Makes it really stand out. Same with when Tara gets shot(really makes you realize JUST how stupid guns are)
 
Beside the whole episode being sad- every scene just seemed to hit home on an all too realistic level, the thing that most particularly made it sad/shocking for me is in the same vein as Xander's though process.

You know where he's trying to find a reason but there isn't any? There's no one to blame. I mean with Buffyverse death there's usually cause or reason- Jenny died because Angelus wished to torture Giles and Buffy, Angel 'died'(in Becoming) to stop Acathla, Buffy died to save the world and her sister, even Tara's death happened for a reason in the fact that it was at the hands of a maddened Warren. But with Joyce there was no one to blame and no reason for it. It just was. We/The characters couldn't go 'Oh well she died because of this' because there was no because it just happened and as I said before that's a reality we don't often see in Buffy, but we see all the time in our own lives. Hence uncomfortably sad.

But each of the characters different reactions were the saddest moments for me. Buffy became a child again- which was in a way making her want her Mom even more, Dawn just couldn't accept it, Willow worrying over the right clothes (and her obsession with wearing the 'blue one'), Xander demanding a reason, Anya not understanding how someone she knew is now gone. It was all just so...heart wrenching. And I don't think anyone who's ever dealt with death can say they didn't ask the questions Anya asked. You do and like Willow basically said, no one has an answer.

Oh! And Dawn's 'Where'd she go?' that made me cry. I remember thinking the exact same thing as I looked at my Grandmother's casket after she died. And I was in my 20s and I still asked that question. It just doesn't make sense that this person you loved and used to smile at you and be full of life is just suddenly empty like a shell. And Dawn asking that question really captured that feeling.

But everything about that episode- the camera direction, the writing, the acting, the mise-en-scene..all of it. Made up for one BIIIIG LOOOONG sad moment.
 
S
StuckinTraffic
[No message]
As I've said before, I'm one of the tiny minority who don't get moved by that ep much, as I never liked Joyce at all and thus didn't feel a loss when she died (cruel thing to say, I know - but I'm just being honest here).

However, on recently rewatching the ep even I got a moment of sadness/pain seeing Willow totally go to tears over her failure of finding the "right" sweater (I just love Willow... and AH is one hell of a cryer, marvellous actress!), and of course the moment of bonding between Buffy and Tara was great.
 
Yep- Alyson in sad scenes always make me weepy. She has this amazing ability to go 'YOU WILL CRY WITH ME. YOU WILL CRY WITH WILLOW'. I think Joss said he and the writers dubbed her 'Queen of Pain'
 
F
Five
Exactly!!!
C
Charlie Kaur
Oh yes, Alyson is amazing at crying so convincing, I've tried to copy her once or twice. It's very difficult!
W
wehappyfew
haha nice.
Yep- Alyson in sad scenes always make me weepy. She has this amazing ability to go 'YOU WILL CRY WITH ME. YOU WILL CRY WITH WILLOW'. I think Joss said he and the writers dubbed her 'Queen of Pain'

That is so true! And it's not just the horrible death scenes she's in. Even in Welcome to the Hellmouth, after Cordelia makes fun of her dress and she walks away and gives Buffy that look, your heart breaks. I think it's something in her eyes.

Anyway, the first time I watched The Body, I didn't actually start crying until Willow had her clothing problem. Like everyone has said, when she cries, you do, too.

Anya's speech is the runner-up, just because Emma's delivery was incredible. That line just made Joyce's death so much sadder and made death in general seem more confusing. It was nice to see that she could actually act as something other than the "dumb girl."
 
It was nice to see that she could actually act as something other than the "dumb girl."

Too true. They use Anya so often as comic relief that it was nice to see her Emma in this very dramatic, serious and sad part. Very moving. I think throughout the episode Anya is like the role of the child. When someone dies in a family there are often children there and they are the ones who ask the same question Anya does- 'Are we going to see the body?' for example.
I remember when I was five and my grandfather (Mom's Father) died and I said to my Mother, who was obviously upset, can we go see him? My mother laughed despite the tragedy because she could hear her Dad saying 'Morbid child....'. But it's just the trying-to-comprehend attitude children tend to have.
 
I have to go for the Anya scene as well because for me it gets to the core of death - you're there one minute, doing normal things and then you're not and you never do those things again. Ever. Emma does a beautiful job (even if she did need to pee at the time (as she said at the recent reunion)).
 
J
Joyce Summers
Haha about Emma's behind-the-scene quote. It made me laugh when she was saying that.
EVERYTHING! nope maybe when the paramedics are about to come in and she pulls he moms skirt down a little, you know the bit i mean?

anya's speech gets me, and willows freak out, xander putting his hand through the wall.... little dawnie in the morgue eugh... okay im welling up now...
 
All of it. But the two saddest parts for me; Anya's speech and when Buffy imagines her Mom alive again, then just to cut back to her lying dead...That breaks my heart.
 
The Body was so brilliantly crafted that its hard to narrow things down. The episode is just so full of moments that tug at the heart. The whole atmosphere really reinforced the emotions of the episode for me. Against a silent backdrop with little distraction from the fulll weight of the situation, I just really felt myself being pulled into the moment.
 
For me this episode just gets right to the core. The whole first act where Buffy finds her mum and its one long shot of her panicking, very little cutting... its as if its just happening, very real. The whole 'Mummy' thing as well. I think its one of the first times i actually thought of Buffy as being a child once, because shes normally all 'lets-save-the-world-blah-blah-blah' (not meant to sound as if im taking the micky but i realise it does slightly so i apologise for that). Basically its her being a kid again, not knowing how to cope with a situation. Thats a moment.
Next i have to say the whole Willow scenes. As has been mentioned here many a time, Allison just has that thing that makes you cry, i dont know what it is... the eyes, the desperation, the geekyness... i dont know but she has something that everytime chokes me up.
The next is Anya... Up until that point i cried slightly, got a little choked up and a bit snotty if you know what i mean... but when Anya gives that speech... i broke down completally. I was watching it on DVD and i had to actually stop it because i couldnt see my eyes were so red and watery. I was heartbroken. Its like when your a kid and you ask things because you really dont understand and people get all annoyed at you for asking when really all you need is some kind of answer... i relate to that alot. Its very real i think, and up until that point Anya was the one who was funny and sometimes annoying but always sweet, and then we se her like that and it blows her character fully open and reveals a new side. I liked her a heck of a lot more after that.
Another thing is just seeing the body its-self. Its kind of creepy but at the same time beautiful because you know who this person has been and how she spent her last few weeks, and although she had hard times she had her family there and brings that point home. I dont know, the whole episode for me was really poignant.
Another thing was the Dawn thing... like when shes crying because that guy said that she was strange or whatever, and she thinks its the worse thing in the world, and then just moments later she finds out her mum is dead... i think it makes you see that small things are small and we can see them as big things until something really big comes along. Its also i think the point where she grows up and matures alot in herself, that moment when she turns around and sees Buffy.
Oh and another thing, i think it really hits home how important Giles is to Buffy. What with him being the first person she calls. I think he is really her father figure and i know the point came up before and since but it really sets it in stone i think and thats a sweet moment.

Gosh, i could on a lot longer but i think i have repetitive strain injury now and i really need a drink....
x
 
For me, the saddest part was the scene with Anya, Xander Willow and Tara in the dormitory. With Anya not understanding everything and Xander just feeling angry and upset. Willow crying about how she thinks her outfit might be offensive to Buffy and Tara trying to calm the situation down as much as she could.

For me it just showed the close connection between all the characters. The way it was done is just so amazing.
 
ItMustBeBunnies
ItMustBeBunnies
[No message]
This entire episode is just so well done that I feel dreadful right from seeing the flowers. Two moments stand out in particular though. The first is where Buffy imagines Joyce being ressucitated, and you get all the flash cuts of her recovery, suddenly juxtaposed with the body. Having been in a very similar situation, I know exactly how that feels. I think it would probably seem a little silly or cliché to someone who hasn't been there, but it really hit home for me.

The second bit was Willow. Not so much her crying (although that is heartbreaking), but her frantic obsession over a tiny thing. It's those kind of small touches that have obviously been thought of by someone who has been there that really make this episode for me.
 
The whole scene with Willow and her clothes is brilliant and is also my favorite.
- God, why do all my shirts have such stupid things on them?

Xanders fist in the wall, another favorite. That you don't get to see it makes it even better.
- Did I miss something?
- Xander decided that he blames the wall.


I also loves the forward flash where Joyce survives, and then it gets back to body.
Have never experienced anything like that (luckily) but it just seems so right and possible to me.

/SK
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom