Which is better

I like both the series, they are very different but if I would have to pic I'd go with Charmed 😉
 
Smallville or Charmed?

I haven't been an avid follower of either from their birth, but from what i have seen Smallville is definitely the better of the two. A sister appearing out of nowhere? Mystical pregnancies? Anyone here watch Buffy?!?! Cause Charmed sounds like a slight rip off if you ask me. A friend even found an interview with the producer where he practically confessed to ripping off other people's ideas from the internet! Something about "checking out what the fans want", more like checking out how the Buffy storylines are working out if you ask me. And come on, Smallville has Lex! That man is nice to look at!
 
Don't like either too much... did like smallville, but i've gone off it lately...

i think i prefer smallville, more drama (slightly) but the acting is probably better in charmed...i think tom welling is too wooden to be a lead...
 
Re: Smallville or Charmed?

Originally posted by Philomela
I haven't been an avid follower of either from their birth, but from what i have seen Smallville is definitely the better of the two. A sister appearing out of nowhere? Mystical pregnancies? Anyone here watch Buffy?!?! Cause Charmed sounds like a slight rip off if you ask me. A friend even found an interview with the producer where he practically confessed to ripping off other people's ideas from the internet! Something about "checking out what the fans want", more like checking out how the Buffy storylines are working out if you ask me. And come on, Smallville has Lex! That man is nice to look at!
Click to expand...

There's a lot of comparisons with Smallville and Buffy as well. I think if a particular show has a big fan base then other writers are going to try and re-capture that. I don't really compare Charmed with Buffy. I think that's an original show....sure some storylines are similar but they are both sci-fi shows, so that's to be expected.

Out of the 2 shows Charmed and Smallville I prefer Charmed. I do like Smallville though.
 
Re: Re: Smallville or Charmed?

Originally posted by Philomela
I haven't been an avid follower of either from their birth, but from what i have seen Smallville is definitely the better of the two. A sister appearing out of nowhere? Mystical pregnancies? Anyone here watch Buffy?!?! Cause Charmed sounds like a slight rip off if you ask me. A friend even found an interview with the producer where he practically confessed to ripping off other people's ideas from the internet! Something about "checking out what the fans want", more like checking out how the Buffy storylines are working out if you ask me. And come on, Smallville has Lex! That man is nice to look at!
Click to expand...

Originally posted by Jules
There's a lot of comparisons with Smallville and Buffy as well. I think if a particular show has a big fan base then other writers are going to try and re-capture that. I don't really compare Charmed with Buffy. I think that's an original show....sure some storylines are similar but they are both sci-fi shows, so that's to be expected.

Out of the 2 shows Charmed and Smallville I prefer Charmed. I do like Smallville though.
Click to expand...

I don't think Buffy and Charmed is that much alike. Anyway to me no offense to Smallville fans. But I Think it sucks. I told my best friend that. She flip. Cause she thinks the guy in the show is Hot. lol Anyway, Anyone here watch Superman or Rosewell?!?! lol lol Smallville is like Superman and kinda like Rosewell. But that's my opinon. Everyone has there own opinions.

Well anyway That's Easy. Charmed All the way. Charmed is the best!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom