Who Should Of Became A Scooby???

[Lee]

I like

Spoiler

Nancy from 'Beneath You' I liked the way she talked and the way she was around them, im guessing im the only one though!

 

[Lilah]

I liked Nancy!!! I also like Cassie, but she is so dead now!!! And I also like RJ!!!

 

[Buffy16Angel]

I didn't really like RJ. Cassie would have been a Scooby member, but it's too bad she died. 🙁

 

[Lee]

I dont really like anyone listed there, the only person i would choose is the one i chose (look up!)

 

[Lilah]

Well Nancy wasnt in Season 1 to 3 while Buffy and the scoobys were in high school!!! So thats why she isnt on the list!!!

 

[Nightspirit]

Definetly Amy, i always hoped she would stay on the show permanently as a main character.

 

[BuffyUKer]

Originally posted by Seeing Red
I didnt put Andrew on the list because he wasnt shown in Season 1 to 3!!!

my bad! sorry. i would have wanted Amy as a scooby... but not now!

 

[Khaych]

Johnathon all the way. He makes a way better loser than Xander. 🙂

Larry would have been all right, though. I was actually disappointed when he got chomped in Graduation Day.

 

[Lilah]

I was too, I would of liked to see him at the college!!!

 

[buffygirlfranny]

Larry because then he would have stayed on the show for longer and my some of the funniest season two and three moments were with him and xander.

 

[*Lost Angel*]

I think andrew would of made a great scobby before, he was sooooooo funny.

Dru

 

[Argie]

Amy. She was the only one that they ever seemed on frienldy terms with them in the first place.

Harmony: Would have hated being in with them, or would have eventually betrayed them because she had no reason to join them. Cordy had a guy. Harmony was too much of a sheep. A definate follower. The "I'll do what everyone else is doing, so I can say I did it first." NO!

Johnathon: What? No! He would have been worse off than Xander! He would have been the quiet guy that always got kidnapped!

Larry: Well, I can't say a definate "no," but no.

And on Lily: If they make another spin-off: MAKE HER A MAIN CHARACTER! Or, hey, she could still be living in L.A.!... One of the things that Buffy told her at the end of "Anne" was that learning to take care of yourself takes practice. Well, she would have taken that to heart and would be better for it!

 

[Werewolf@Night]

I voted other, I would want Faith to join the scoobies and stay

 

[MagicalMe]

Amy. Then she maybe wouldnt have done what she did. (w/ reference to spoiler WiccanWillow stated)

 

[charmedbuffyuk]

I voted Johnathen as I think he deserved to be a scooby after chosen

 

[DáNió]

I voted Jonathon

 

[Prio Motu]

I would say Amy, she was cool. But definately NOT Jonathan, I absolutely despise him, so much that if he had joined the scoobies, it may have put me off watching.

 

[AngelsBaby]

Originally posted by MagicalMe
Amy. Then she maybe wouldnt have done what she did. (w/ reference to spoiler WiccanWillow stated)

I agree and I also chose Amy.

 

[Kendra]

i voted for other/kendra

 

[Jules]

I voted Larry coz his and Xander's scenes together were so funny 🙂