I voted for Anya. I've never really thought they actually did love each other because they never acted very serious together, but after i watched the wedding ep i completely changed my mind, that episode was so sad and then when i saw Anya crying i was nearly crying too, but the part that really hit me was when Anya was going over her vows and couldn't decide what to say, but when she finally got it right it sounded like it really came from the heart and that she really did love him.