Who would win in a fight Xander or Andrew?

[Blade69]

So who do u think would win?
All I could think about when Xan & Harmony went at it, LOL!!!! it was like a slap fest.

 

[Randy Giles]

Xander, I think, unless Andrew just slapped him so much Xander couldn't get a punch in. 🙂 I'd root for Andrew though, simply because he's hilarious.

 

[definition of insane]

It would have to be Xander....but I honestly never understood why that fight was a slapfest (other than being incredibly funny). Xander has punched vamps and others before....maybe it was just high school solidarity.

But then again...maybe Andrew turns into a master of Drunken Boxing and wipes the floor with Xander....

 

[MarsGirl]

Definitely Xander. At least he doesn't scream "I have swimmer's ear!" to defend himself...heh.

 

[Lyri]

i always wondered if the Xander/Harmony fight scene was because it was Harmony. Xander knew her before she got vamped. she was someone he grew up with, like Willow and Cordy. maybe his mind was having trouble dealing with the fact that she was the bad guy now, and he was supposed to kill her. he's mind was probably telling him 'don't hit the girl!' or something.

but yeah, Xander all the way! 😀

 

[white avenger]

Would this be hand to hand, or with light sabers? With his fists, Angel would have the advantage unless Andrew could bob and weave, float like a butterfly, sting like a bee, and reach out to the Force. If he could drag the fight out, Xander's excess lard would be his downfall in the end.

With light sabers, Andrew is by far the most experienced Jedi Knight, so Xander wouldn't stand a chance.
[br][/br]
Edit:
[br][/br]
Oops! In my comment above, I of course meant "With his fists, XANDER would have the advantage, not Angel. Sorry about that,