Who's Best of the Best in BTVS

[LazyDolphin]

I ultimately went with Alyson, although I think that they're both fantastic and I think they have very similar strengths as actresses. They both do the vulnerable or hurt thing extremely well. They're both great at drama and often quite funny, but I think Alyson is a little bit more of a natural silly/funny comedic actress, so I went with her.

 

[blake]

I'd have ty say Alyson, although SMG breaks my heart at the emotional stuff, coming from an actor, Alyson hannigan's character would have just been a harder part to play. That and when you see her, during the emotional scenes, she just seems more convincing.

Not that Sarah isn't!

 

[polexia]

Originally posted by slayer007
I went with Alyson, mainly because of how Willow has changed throughout the years. AH has really portrayed every characterization of Willow Joss has thrown her really well.

i went with AH cos of the same reason.. this was a though one nerd4hire!! really...

 

[Chasity]

I think that they are both really great actresses. I went with Alyson because I have really like her acting outside of her character Willow. I have not really like anything SMG has done outside of Buffy. I will admit it when I do but until then Alyson wins for me.

 

[Utopia]

Wow, what a toughie. In the end, I had to go with ... Sarah. Maybe it's because I've seen her in more roles but I just love her acting style. She can pull off a lot of different things and I appluad her for that.

I'm also not saying Alyson can't do the same thing. I just think it's because I haven't seen her in as many roles to compare the two. *shrug*

 

[Lilah]

Alyson Hannigan! 🙂🙂🙂