Willow vs. The Charmed Ones
- Thread starter Joshua
- Start date
V
Vamp Jenny
Guest
I'd say Willow. She has all the powers within herself, while the Charmed Ones have to be together to be as strong as she is. They can't read within each other's mind and be as synchronised as her. Plus, I don't think Phoebe would be of much help because she rarely have premonitions during a fight...
It would be a tough fight. And Phoebe's power isn't just about the visions, she has all the levitating and empathy stuff going on! Also she's a great fighter and her premonition power extends in that, it is shown in different episodes that she ducks attacks more easily because of some kind of sixth sense! 😀
MikeyTheWatcher
Potential
Aw poor Shannen 🙁
Anywhoo, between the Charmed ones and regular Willow I'm not sure why they would be fighting but it seems to be that it would be fairly even as their powers seem to be on about an equal level (counting the Charmed ones power as one as it kind of functions since they're weaker apart)
Between the Charmed ones and Evil Willow however... I can't help but feel that the Charmed ones would be the sore losers of that fight. Evil Willow on the top of her came would just walk into their manor and take them out one by one (unless she was distracted by Phoebe's charms 😉 Hey it's happened.... 😀)
Nix
[No message]
I would most definitely put my bet on Willow, unless the charmed ones had the book of shadows in front of them with a willow vanquishing spell then they'd be pretty much useless. If willow can take on a God and hold her own for a short time, then she'd make short work of the charmed ones.
S
SlayerOfVampyrs
EXACTLY what I was thinking!
Evil Angelus 95
Total Dork
Spiral
Vortex
The charmed ones have faced evil witches before.
Willow would be overwhelmed by the Charmed Ones. She wouldnt be fighting ppl who care about her or who had concerns about hurting her.
The sisters have the advantage of numbers, range & each of them has powers that can give Willow problems on many fronts.
Any energy projection she sends their way can be turned back on her by Prue or Paige. Prue & Paige could also attack her physical body in various manners from a distance.
Piper's temporal stasis & molecular acceleration attacks could be used to strike @ Willow w/ the environment around her (freezing/slowing down her physical movements or projectiles OR blowing the ground she's standing on, or blowing up objects around her causing them to crash down upon her etc)
Willow is a lousy physical fighter & would be less than no match for Phoebe in a physical fight especially if Phoebe has her premonition & levitation in tact.
the Book of Shadows would most likely be the tool used in Willow's final destruction/vanquish.
Willow would be overwhelmed by the Charmed Ones. She wouldnt be fighting ppl who care about her or who had concerns about hurting her.
The sisters have the advantage of numbers, range & each of them has powers that can give Willow problems on many fronts.
Any energy projection she sends their way can be turned back on her by Prue or Paige. Prue & Paige could also attack her physical body in various manners from a distance.
Piper's temporal stasis & molecular acceleration attacks could be used to strike @ Willow w/ the environment around her (freezing/slowing down her physical movements or projectiles OR blowing the ground she's standing on, or blowing up objects around her causing them to crash down upon her etc)
Willow is a lousy physical fighter & would be less than no match for Phoebe in a physical fight especially if Phoebe has her premonition & levitation in tact.
the Book of Shadows would most likely be the tool used in Willow's final destruction/vanquish.
Faith
Covered all the bases on that one!
Lets not forget the fact that Dark Willow was fuelled by her personal attachments. While emotions will power you so far they also become your greatest weakness as you don't think tactically, you act first leaving yourself open to exposure - pretty much like a boxer.
Spiral
Vortex
exactly. it was emotions flaring due to her personal attachments that feuled her & the appeal to those emotions that ultimately brought Dark Willow down.
that & the fact that she was fighting ppl who were hesitant to really hurt her. the charmed ones, especially Prue, would have no hesitation about striking her down.
Also, Willow's spells usually took some prep time, whereas the Charmed Ones' powers were more instantaneous, so I think they would just overwhelm her.
The ONLY thing in her favor is that IF we say Willow is a witch the same way the Charmed Ones are (which you could say she's not a natural witch and this wouldn't even apply) Piper can't freeze her. Because if Piper could freeze her, game over.
The ONLY thing in her favor is that IF we say Willow is a witch the same way the Charmed Ones are (which you could say she's not a natural witch and this wouldn't even apply) Piper can't freeze her. Because if Piper could freeze her, game over.
Last edited by a moderator:
SlayerFest
Wiley Dairy Gnome
I really don't think that Willow would stand a chance. Her power started to drain at one point and I don't recall Prue, Piper, Phoebe or Paige ever having that problem. When she first started "draining" couldn't they have locked her in one of those...crystal things? I haven't seen that show in the longest haha.
Spiral
Vortex
Yeah, Piper couldn't freeze good witches If I remember correctly. Seems to me like Willow would fall into the same category as Tuatha, the evil witch from season 2.
btvsfanatic
[No message]
Regular willow may be a lousy fighter, but she held her own against a slayer as dark willow, so I doubt phoebe would be much of a problem.
Willow watch this....
Willow goes agenst the charmed one holds her own for awile,the tide turns she starts to lose taps both sides of her powers the dark and the light bringing out Willows more devious nature
Willow feeds fake prementions to Phoebe Phoebe takes the bait and wham Willows puts one of the girls though a portal to the shrimp demention breaking up the power of three
Willow then soaks up the Book Of Shadows into herself And its all over
Willow goes agenst the charmed one holds her own for awile,the tide turns she starts to lose taps both sides of her powers the dark and the light bringing out Willows more devious nature
Willow feeds fake prementions to Phoebe Phoebe takes the bait and wham Willows puts one of the girls though a portal to the shrimp demention breaking up the power of three
Willow then soaks up the Book Of Shadows into herself And its all over
Evil Angelus 95
Total Dork
...As a fan of both sides, I'm torn here.
Still, Willow would probably have an advantage considering the sere amount of magick that she can control, but eventually the Charmed Ones would come out on top, if not because of the power that they themselves can control. But then again, you never know what could happen.
Still, Willow would probably have an advantage considering the sere amount of magick that she can control, but eventually the Charmed Ones would come out on top, if not because of the power that they themselves can control. But then again, you never know what could happen.
iShower4free
Scooby
It's all comes down to what world this is. The charmed ones are the most powerful witches in their world and so are we bringing Willow there? And even on neutral ground Willow still needs to lose control in order to become dark willow. No way regular willow beats the charmed ones in a fight. A charmed one, one in one sure. But together they can take her.
btvsfanatic
The ***** is back
...In the end the charmed ones would win.
Sure they would struggle and willow would struggle but If you think about it the charmed ones also have The power of three spell (used in the very first episode) If they used that and everything that [MENTION=1976]Spiral[/MENTION] said they would win!!
Sure they would struggle and willow would struggle but If you think about it the charmed ones also have The power of three spell (used in the very first episode) If they used that and everything that [MENTION=1976]Spiral[/MENTION] said they would win!!