Would you think Buffy's insane as well?

J

Joshua

Huge Spuffy Fan!
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
1,392
Age
34
Location
Sunnydale
In "Living Conditions" every one thinks she's insane, even though they have been friends for a long time. Question is: If you were one of the Scoobies would you had thought Buffy was insane as well?
 
I think I would think she is insane as well. I don't want to say I would be much different than the other Scoobies. Unfortunately...
 
Buffy's been wrong how many times? I'd be a little unsure, yeah, but if Buffy was really adamant about it, I think I'd tend to believe her.
 
Ok... random weird quirk about me: I LOVE bad roommate stories. I adore them. I've never had to have a roommate... so that's probably why I find them so fun and hysterical... But I would probably want to see for myself. So I'd probably be like "we should stake out your room together. Like I'll come stay in your room or something." And I'd probably stalk Kathy and keep an eye on her trying to see every awful thing Buffy saw so I could develop my own opinion.
 
I wouldn't think she was insane. I'd probably write it off as Buffy being overly territorial due to having to share a room and her things for the first time.
 
I wouldn't think she was insane. I love this episode (where my username comes from BTW), but I hate the way her friends treat her because I mean, Buffy wasn't really acting insane. It's normal to hate your roommate and to be completely annoyed by them, and yes she thought she was a demon... But she was right, wasn't she? I think they got too out of hand when they tied her up and thought she was possessed. I always thought that was very over-dramatic.
 
BuffyElevated
BuffyElevated
[No message]
I always thought it odd that they didn't give her the benefit of the doubt. She's saved Sunnydale 30-odd times and the world a few times by now. She can spot when something is up. Granted they did play it as though the demon accusation was just a part of her frustration, but Buffy's say so merits a little investigation in my opinion.
 
Absolutely not.

If the Slayer says that something is demonic and evil then it is demonic and evil. Period. Buffy is a supernatural being specialized in killing all things evil and demonic, she has "spidey sense" and slayer dreams, she knows better.

Her friends not trusting her I can understand ( barely, after years of fighting alongside her ) Giles, I cannot. I think it just shows his incompetence as a watcher.
 
I wouldn't think she was insane but I can understand them thinking it's just that she's having difficulty having to share her space with someone after being an only child but as the episode goes on you would think they would know her well enough by then to realise somthing else was going on IMO
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom